The Iceman vs Manning

[NEO]

You got one game.

You have no idea who the opponent is and your soul is on the line, eternal heaven or hell.

The opponent could be any team. Florida, Bama, Ga....

You don’t know the opponent until kick off.

You have to pick either Casey or Peyton as your QB.

Who you pick?

 

[knucklehead_vol]

I picked Casey.

 

[99gator]

I would not think something like this would even be up for debate.

 

[GAVol]

I would not think something like this would even be up for debate.

It's February on Volnation. No debate is too stupid.

 

[Notorious B.E.N]

Peyton

 

[Grudenhaslanded]

Peyton would choke on his own tongue and still hasn’t beaten Florida.

 

[GAVol]

Peyton would choke on his own tongue and still hasn’t beaten Florida.

And Casey Clausen lost 2 Peach Bowls That ended with the opposing fans chanting "A-C-C".

 

[CA_Vol]

I would not think something like this would even be up for debate.

Buzz off, nerd. Go wash your jorts.

 

[ABINGDON VOL FAN]

Peyton would choke on his own tongue and still hasn’t beaten Florida.

LOL, I still have doubts about you as a Vol fan. First PF and now Manning. Is this blue font or are you deliberately trying to rile people?

 

[PhoenixAZVol]

Good grief. Only a month and a half since the season ended and we are already getting these ‘boredom’ threads. Come on, the Florida teams Manning played were much better than the teams Clausen played (maybe excluding 2001). Peytons overall body of work was better as well. Clausen was very good but he had a 4 loss season and a 5 loss season and lost to two inferior ACC teams in bowls.

 

[VFLEatinFresh]

Remember that SNL skit where Will Ferrell played Harry Caray and asked that guy “would you rather be the top scientist in your field or get mad cow disease?”

This is nearly that level of a question.

 

[JOEY'S ALL VOL !!!]

It's February on Volnation. No debate is too stupid.

Can we poll this ?

 

[golfballs]

You got one game.

You have no idea who the opponent is and your soul is on the line, eternal heaven or hell.

The opponent could be any team. Florida, Bama, Ga....

You don’t know the opponent until kick off.

You have to pick either Casey or Peyton as your QB.

Who you pick?

 

[BigOrangeTrain]

Peyton would choke on his own tongue and still hasn’t beaten Florida.

Lol. You think Clausen beat UF in 2001 dont you?

 

[Otis07]

Clausen at Miami in the Orange Bowl stadium was a masterful piece of quarterbacking

 

[HarderKnox59]

Who has the most Road wins in the state of Florida ?

 

[madbamahater]

Peyton didn't single handily lose those games to Florida. Tennessee's defenses lost those games.

Peyton did, however, completely own Bama and Georgia.

 

[VolsnRavens]

"Clausen's first start was a 20-10 win over Alabama on Oct. 21, 2000, the first of three victories against the Crimson Tide. As a starter, Clausen was 5-2 against Alabama and Florida, 4-0 in Tuscaloosa and Gainesville. "

Let that sink in 4-0 in Tuscaloosa and Gainesville. I'll always be a Peyton fan, but Casey was such a fun QB to watch. Especially in other teams stadiums.

 

[MemphisVol77]

Is it a home game, neutral site, or on the road? Or is that unknown as well?

 

[JonGrudensAgent]

Considering it doesn't specify their college eras or overall body of work I'm going with the guy who made multiple Super Bowls.

 

[jeff1vol]

If we are playing UF... it's Clausen and not even a question.

Having said that... I'd still have to go with CC over PM. Even though against everyone else, it's a very tough pick.

CC was one stone cold killer! Only ONE road loss in his career at UT! ONE!

 

[rjd970]

Based on the probability of win and not knowing the opponent I’m going with Peyton.

That said, if we run out of the tunnel and Florida is staring at us I would regret the decision.

 

[livefaith]

I would not think something like this would even be up for debate.

It's not. This isn't real. It can't be.

 

[n_huffhines]

Some serious cognitive bias up in here. People think just because a couple things happened at memorable times that they are likely to happen again. Look at the body of work. Peyton won a lot of big games on both levels.

Peyton was 32-5 his last 3 years and Clausen was 39-10. Peyton put up bigger stats. What else do people need to see?

 

[orangebloodgmc]

Freak, y'all REALLY need to bring back the ignore thread feature, please.