Johnny Majors and Peyton Manning should be Heisman winners. That’s why most Vols don’t like the media imo.
I agree on Johnny Majors but I see some logic with Peyton Manning. It is hard to remove the NFL Career from the College Career but Manning had some bad games in College.
In the 1997 season alone, he struggled in a loss to Florida and struggled heavily against Vanderbilt. I also think he had a meh game against South Carolina. This was after the Heisman but he practically disappeared against Nebraska as well.
There really wasn't some great comeback performance or dominate game by Manning like you saw in his NFL career.
I think this all lead to the media turning against him.
I also think Tennessee has fallen flat on its face many times over last 15 years that makes people still not want to trust Tennessee. Even during our high point with Fulmer, we only claimed 2 Conference Titles and 1 National Title. Les Miles at LSU had more than Fulmer when it comes to actual championships.
Under Fulmer, we were not that great sometimes in major bowl games (1994 Penn State, 1997 Nebraska, 1999 Nebraska, 2000 Kansas State, 2002 Maryland, 2003 Clemson, 2009 Penn State).
We did not have that DOMINANT run. Take Spurrier at Florida who won the SEC in 1991, 1993, 1994, 1995, 1996, and 2000. That is 6 SEC Championships to Fulmer's 2.
Tennessee just hasn't won consistently at the high level back to back to back years like other SEC programs. The only time we Tennessee even comes close to the dominance of Florida under Spurrier, Alabama under Saban, or Georgia with Kirby Smart was during the Bob Neyland era when no one really paid attention because games were not televised heavily.
So as a program, we tend to always be second or third fiddle to another SEC program when we have been up and we have been very bad the last 15 or so years. We have also played with people's heart. In 2016 we were preseason top ten and fell apart, in 2012 we got ranked and fell apart, in 2020 we were preseason top 20 and fell apart. Even going back to Fulmer era, we had two preseason top 5 teams that collapsed and finished outside the polls: 2002 and 2005.
If we look in the mirror, we have earned some of this hate.