You seem to argue on both sides. paraphrased but you stated something like "Auburn beat Tennessee so their 3-5 record doesn't matter" and now it doesn't matter that Tennessee beat Georgia?
And I know this is not the "end all be all", but has anyone looked at the poll on Outback Bowl College Football Game ? It shows UT and UK getting 31% a pc of the fans vote while AU only has 11%. If Auburn goes to the outback over UT I will be very angry, especially if it is because they "promise" to sell more tickets. Everyone knows that UT travels well and will sell as many tickets as the next guy. If AU goes for that reason its horse****! I love watching college football more than anything else but I have to say that the way these bowls are picked completely takes all credibility out of the selection system. We need a playoff of some sort!
More convenient site is a plus.
Primetime is a plus.
Better opponent is a plus.
Va Tech's offense vs Monte's defense worries me. The wildcat/option offense has given him fits (see Mark Ingram in the wildcat, Dexter McCluster anywhere on the field, Randall Cobb anywhere on the field, etc).
Recruiting hotbed...big plus.
.
My argument was that they beat us on our homefield, and that they played in a tougher division than us. We went 0-3 against the SEC west.
Guys, I am hoping we do get selected above these teams, but I am not some sort of blind homer that thinks we had an amazing season and deserve the Cotton or Outback. We had 8 home games. We played 0 ranked teams at home and went 6-2 in Neyland. We only have 7 wins. This is as easy a schedule as Tennessee will see and we won 7.