I think it's possible to put the blame squarely on Butch & Pals for creating this mess, Butch specifically for making promises he didn't intend to keep. Same with Debord for having the dumbest and most easy to scheme playbook out there.
But I also don't think very highly of a quitter and Hurd's attitude has been apparent all season long. Wish the guy well, but you don't quit on a team when things aren't going your way. Overcome adversity and move on after the season.
Do you really believe Butch promised J. Hurd that he was gonna change the offense to suit his needs? Or lied about that in an attempt to trick him?
That is beyond preposterous.
J. Hurd didn't notice in spring practice, summer practice, or earlier in the season "oh darn!, they're not doing what they said they'd do"!! 8 games into the year a man has gotta draw a line in the sand you see.
Maybe Hurd listened to bad advice from his family.
Maybe when the coaching staff discussed practicing or running the I formation, J. Hurd interpreted that as "I'm the star they're gonna feature me". That sounds plausible to me. I've lost track of the amount of employees I've questioned about their abilty to handle managerial responsibility. The ones that got big heads and told co-workers that they we're being promoted failed my test. People hear what they want to hear.
I'm not trying to claim Butch is Einstein. But even in lesser conferences, nobody dumb enough to promise a player they were gonna change the entire offense to the players preference ever becomes a head coach.
Even if Butch were the exception to the stupidity rule, which you seem inclined to believe, Butch would cater to Dobbs on more designed QB runs and less pocket passes. The law of stupidity would still leave J.Hurd without his I-Formation.
Alex Johnson, C. Maggit, JRM, Cam Sutton, A Kamara, all trusted and respected Butch enough to come back. Could that possibly be indicative of his character as a whole and an attribute as a coach?
Now suddenly J. Hurd has exposed Butch as a diabolical liar with a self serving agenda. J. Hurd is the first victim. Ignore Alvin Kamara's stretches of limited touches early in the year BTW.
Yes, yes, yes. The coaches are clearly at fault of driving Hurd out of the program before he could become the all time UT rushing leader in the wrong formation. I wonder what kind of tall tales Butch told Kamara to trick him into staying. I bet he promised Kamara 4 touches to every one touch Hurd receives this year. Any lie to keep his players from the brutal truth that they will be used in a complimentary manner with the rest of the team.
The possibility that Hurd is under performing and has maturity issues is absurd. Clearly this is our coaches fault. I bet Butch instructed the entire team not to celebrate with him and let him sit by himself on the bench after scoring agsinst USCe last Saturday. That is clearly the coaches fault the team didn't want to celebrate with Hurd. I bet it didn't have anything to do with Hurd's maturity level.
Do you really believe that the coaching staff lied to a player about changing the entire offense to suit that one players particularly skill set, yet kept it private from the public?
There are so many layers of contradictory stupidity involved in the notion that Butch and staff intentionally lied to Hurd about changing the offense to suit him that it becomes absurd to contemplate it having any real validity.
Maybe a seemingly for sure mid-round draft pick's stock has been falling due to a multitude of variables? Maybe that player made a selfish decision to project all fault outwardly?
Nah, it's Butch's fault. Butch lied to Hurd.
Edit:
DooleyOrangePants
That was not a personal attack on you btw. I've seen that alleged change to an I-Form ruse suggested tons of times today.
Meant they rhetoricalrhetorically for everyonev that does believe it.
You post was just the one I got a chance to respond to first.