I agree with everything in your post except the first sentence.  I think, given the players he has had available, Barnes has done a solid job this year.  Winning and losing is not always just attributable to a coach.  Sometimes it is, but not the Vols this year.  Given what we lost and when we lost them, this season was about what I expected.  Historically, most freshmen look just like what we have, or worse.  The Fab Five don't come around very often although I have high hopes for next year's young ones.