Simms vs Crompton

[NEO]

Who is better?

 

[colorado king]

Really?

 

[dembewbs]

Peyton Manning

 

[Cheese Donkey]

At this point in the game I'd say Crompton.

 

[I_Bleed_Orange77]

Oh. My. God.
Posted via VolNation Mobile

 

[RockyTop411]

The guy who led us to a 7-6 season, after getting death threats. Crompton was a great QB in '09.

 

[NEO]

The guy who led us to a 7-6 season, after getting death threats. Crompton was a great QB in '09.

Really?

 

[VolMaster14]

Is this a serious thread?

 

[volberry]

Crompton just needed proper development. If he had Kiffin a year earlier he would have been awesome at UT. Simms sucks no matter who is developing him.

 

[Cartervol]

Between the two Crompton. Neither if there was a second option.

 

[UTK]

Crompton by miles.

 

[NEO]

Both throw a hell of an interecption if you ask me.

 

[waltsspac]

Crompton

 

[govols120]

Crompton by several miles. The only thing Simms can do well is take a hit.
Posted via VolNation Mobile

 

[mscox75]

Ummmm. 1. Crompton is a Vol. We don't bash. 2. Crompton is in the NFL on a practice squad. Must be good enough to impress someone. 3. I would take Crompton today. 4. Simms is a leader. I ll take him even if we lose. We win together and we lose together.
Posted via VolNation Mobile

 

[005]

Crompton by several miles. The only thing Simms can do well is take a hit.
Posted via VolNation Mobile

Yes. Crompton, and it ain't real close.

 

[Bill4volz]

Crompton was better in 09, i'd take Simms over Crompton of 08.

 

[RockyTop411]

Really?

Really. 27 touchdown passes, 13 interceptions, and a 58.3% completion percentage. 2-1 TD-INT Ratio. With a team with hardly anybody to throw too. DMoore was Ok, Gerald Jones was average in '09. Should've beat Alabama, DMoore drops a TD in the Chick-Fil-A Bowl that turns the Momentum. If both of those happen, we are a 9-4 football team.

 

[btrotter]

Crompton!!!!

 

[10NCVol88]

repeat threads are repeated

 

[vols-1]

Crompton just needed proper development. If he had Kiffin a year earlier he would have been awesome at UT.

No he would not. David Cutcliffe worked with him for two years. He's had great NFL coaches work with him. He was great division 3A player, nothing more nothing less. It took him overtime to beat Kentucky in 2009, not to mention getting getting blown out against Ole Miss as a 5th year senior.

 

[Playwright]

i really don't understand why we don't do more of the rollout pass type offense we did with crompton in 09 for simms.

keeps him out of the pocket from getting sacked and he can dump it outside of the hash marks. why not?

 

[zjcvols]

i really don't understand why we don't do more of the rollout pass type offense we did with crompton in 09 for simms.

keeps him out of the pocket from getting sacked and he can dump it outside of the hash marks. why not?

There are very, very little rollouts in this offense. In a spread offense that Chaney likes to run, you aren't going to see a lot.

In the West Coast, you'll see rollouts. It can be a staple of the offense.

I love the rollout. I think it's a great passing tool, especially if you struggle to read coverages (aka Matt Simms). With Bray, who does a really good job as a sophomore going through his progression, you necessarily don't need to rollout (although it can be a weapon).

We also don't know Simms throws on the run. He might be terrible. SO that might be part of the thought process.

 

[justingroves]

No he would not. David Cutcliffe worked with him for two years. He's had great NFL coaches work with him. He was great division 3A player, nothing more nothing less. It took him overtime to beat Kentucky in 2009, not to mention getting getting blown out against Ole Miss as a 5th year senior.

Potential soup material

 

[NEVolFan]

Who is better?

Really depends on what you are tralking about...

...Grass or fans in the stands.