- Joined
- Mar 23, 2011
- Messages
- 28,590
- Likes
- 27,915
And I think posts calling for Jones to WR, TkJr to LB, Berry to RB, Byrd to DB, etc are entirely unnecessary.
How about we let the coaches who get paid a hell of a lot of money and watch these kids every day in practice decide where they can help the team most.
And I think posts calling for Jones to WR, TkJr to LB, Berry to RB, Byrd to DB, etc are entirely unnecessary.
How about we let the coaches who get paid a hell of a lot of money and watch these kids every day in practice decide where they can help the team most.
People change positions successfully every year, people who get offended at a fans suggestion on a message board are a tad pretentious.
A walk on cb will be going in round of the NFL draft 1 as a LB. A 3 star QB from Louisville got drafted as a first round DE recently. A RB from UCLA will go in the top 100 after a year at cb. A DE from Clemson led the NFL in sacks after moving positions several times in college. How dare a fan, on a message board, entertain such ideas.
-Jennings moved
-Hurd is moving and people were ripped for suggesting it
-Smith has moved twice
Im not saying we should never let a player change positions. Im saying people shouldnt spend all off season clamoring for a position change and then when said player has a bad game or makes a mistake the threads of "CBJ is an idiot for not moving x player to x position."
Did the fans help decide to move any of the players listed? No
Im saying lets let the coaches decide.
...yet uncomfortably true to some extent. It's easy to fall into the old trap of white guy must be a dropback passer and black guy must be an athlete. There's basically a tenth of a second difference in the 40 times for QD and SJ. Nobody is asking if Dormady could play Safety.
I wouldn't call it blatantly racist, but it is feeding a stereotype.
Couple years ago, we badly needed our 3rd string qb to play. Jones is a quarterback, needs to play quarterback imo.
Also, we have no idea how athletic he is, haven't seen him do anything. What if he's a 4.8 guy with poor hands? Who knows if he could even play WR?
This question is quintessential message board fodder imo.
So do you feel it was also stereotyping that led to him being rated the #6 best Dual Threat QB coming out of high school, or could it have been the athletic ability he displayed?
What does that have to do with anything?
I'm just pointing out that some just assume he could play WR, yet have never seen him make a meaningful play with the ball in his hands.
Like I said.... You've never seen anything meaningful that tells you he could play WR. I'm not saying it's automatically race based to ask the question. Just saying it's kind of a lazy thing that some fans still bring up with a black QB sometimes.There are several clips showing him making meaningful plays in the open field in high school. That's why he was listed as a dual threat QB.
There are several valid arguments about the potential importance of a 3rd string QB, but to try to make this about race is utterly ridiculous.
What does that have to do with anything?
I'm just pointing out that some just assume he could play WR, yet have never seen him make a meaningful play with the ball in his hands.
...yet uncomfortably true to some extent. It's easy to fall into the old trap of white guy must be a dropback passer and black guy must be an athlete. There's basically a tenth of a second difference in the 40 times for QD and SJ. Nobody is asking if Dormady could play Safety.
I wouldn't call it blatantly racist, but it is feeding a stereotype.
Hes black so hes obviously a good athlete and can play anywhere on the field, right op?
Im so sick of ignorant fans calling for position changes. Its getting a bit ridiculous now.