Stephen, this page (
Rivals.com Football Recruiting - Rivals.com Football Team Recruiting Rankings Formula) is absolutely critical to understanding just how many points are awarded to any specific recruit. As an illustration of their methodology, consider our recent 5-star wide receiver commitment, Josh Malone. As a 5-star prospect, he automatically receives a "Rivals Rating" of 6.1, which gives him a base total of 150 points. As the 20th ranked prospect nationally (see his Rivals profile or the complete list of Rivals Top 250), he receives an additional 60 points, which means that his commitment to UT is worth 210 points.
The fact that Alabama is rated higher with far fewer commitments is the product of three factors:
(1) Rivals only counts the top 20 recruits in each class for the purposes of comparative ranking.
(2) Alabama has more players ranked high in the Top 250 or even the Top 50, so they receive more bonus points for their commitments than we do.
(3) Tennessee has a sizable number of JUCO commitments. Despite the fact that we have five commitments among the Top 50 JUCO prospects nationally, which is the most for any program in the nation, JUCO players do not receive bonus points for their ranking, only the base total derived from their "Rivals Rating" (e.g. 120 points for a 5.9, 4-star prospect).