Recruiting Forum Football Talk IX

Opening weekend shows once again AP don’t have a clue how to rank teams.

Same idiots that justified us at 24 because of a new QB were trying to convince us Ty Simpson & Bama were loaded & that’s why they were a top 10 team.

🤣😂
giphy.gif
 
I’m going to need an official report on how that Nyck Harbor catch just now is a “touchdown” and the LSU Barion Brown catch was incomplete. Stupid. Hathor didn’t carry the ball through all the way to the ground with firm control, it was still moving.

Nvm my feed is way behind. Glad they got it right.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Enki_Amenra
Catch or nah?
I don't get how he can catch it, get two feet in, then when both the WR and defender are completely out of bounds (both take steps out of bounds after the WR completes the catch), the defender knocks it loose

I've seen countless times in CFB and NFL that the defender hits the ball out once both players are out of bounds and no one cares
 
I don't get how he can catch it, get two feet in, then when both the WR and defender are completely out of bounds (both take steps out of bounds after the WR completes the catch), the defender knocks it loose

I've seen countless times in CFB and NFL that the defender hits the ball out once both players are out of bounds and no one cares

Don’t you have to control the ball all the way to the ground? Thats at least the argument made in the LSU game last night that the receiver broke the plane, possessed it, but didn’t control it all the way through. FWIW, I think last night was clearly a touchdown, but if you overturn that you can’t call this a catch.
 
I.think this is the first season where the raw talent on the team is not the ultimate decider of the games. Used to be talent was stable and knew your system. Now your knitting together a squad of mercenaries. Do it wrong and you get FSU last year. Do it right and you get FSU this year. So weird.
FSU is going to have to beat someone better than Bama before I crown them this year's transfer portal winners. I'm not convinced that QB can beat anyone who forces them to throw.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Enki_Amenra
Advertisement



Back
Top