Recruiting Forum Football Talk II

[MoCo_Vol]

Brady or Montana is the GOAT. No debating that as much as I love Peyton Manning as a QB

Bill ****in Walsh #nuffsaid

Pure all out talent, it’s honestly probably Aaron Rodgers. Amazing arm, amazing awareness, athletic as hell, and takes care of the ball.

 

[Bassmaster_Vol]

Brady or Montana is the GOAT. No debating that as much as I love Peyton Manning as a QB

Nope

 

[nashvol1]

Difference in this game will be QB, what the heck was that throw?

 

[MoCo_Vol]

Pretty wild he’s a leftie too. Can’t recall a team with so many. We have like 4 southpaws don’t we?

Jalen
Santiago
Pons
Fulky
Gaines
James

 

[Bearwallow Bandit]

Would love to be able to say Peyton is the GOAT but he’s just not. Brady is number one, and I think Peyton would be number two. Brady has him beat in almost every category, if not all.

 

[UTMVol76]

Bullish!t

 

[tn88volfan]

Those that watched the game, does Vescovi handle the ball well like Bone did? How’s his speed?

Too many turnovers....draws attention and made some elite passes...elite 3 ball...only 18 years old and is already near/at the same level as Bone IMO

 

[MoCo_Vol]

, I'll also add that he has never played with or against the length or speed that he did today or will in the future. It will be an adjustment, but he had very good potential to be special.

LSU has an elite backcourt. Smart & Mays are NBA prospects without a doubt. To play in game 1 at 18 against them and do what he did was impressive.

 

[SamRebel35]

Tom Brady. GOAT of 4 yard crossing routes.

 

[Bearwallow Bandit]

Brady or Montana is the GOAT. No debating that as much as I love Peyton Manning as a QB

I think Peyton has Montana beat. I’d throw Dan Marino up there as well, even though he doesn’t have any championships.

 

[Odiodin]

First NFL game I’ve watched in a long time. All I have to say is: Tony Romo is a national treasure.

If elected president, I will have him cloned to announce all televised Football games.

 

[tnhunter 10]

LSU has an elite backcourt. Smart & Mays are NBA prospects without a doubt. To play in game 1 at 18 against them and do what he did was impressive.

What's your thoughts on the freshman so far?

 

[yourstruly23]

Brady’s the goat
Peyton is the greatest offensive mind to play the game

 

[MoCo_Vol]

Would love to be able to say Peyton is the GOAT but he’s just not. Brady is number one, and I think Peyton would be number two. Brady has him beat in almost every category, if not all.

Peyton also played in just 266 games.
Brady is at 285, Brees at 275. They both needed a lot more games to catch the Sheriff

 

[scvolfan7]

First NFL game I’ve watched in a long time. All I have to say is: Tony Romo is a national treasure.

If elected president, I will have him cloned to announce all televised Football games.

He’s the only one that gives actual insight into the game

 

[MoCo_Vol]

What's your thoughts on the freshman so far?

Overall this is a damn good foundation class. Wish we could RS Olivier, Gaines & Pember they all 3 will be good solid players with more development.

James & Santiago are both gonna have legit shots to play in the league one day. I selfishly hope we keep both 3 years.

 

[BennisDrewer]

Sure. He’s a great QB. But I think it’s dumb to call someone the goat cause he has Super Bowl rings. He wouldn’t have those rings if he didn’t play for the Patriots, at least not as many if any at all. Is he any less of a player if he plays for the browns and wins no super bowls?

Kind of Ironic you could change the names to Jordan and Lebron and have the exact same narrative.

 

[Cosmo Kramer]

Remove the Orange Colored Glasses. If u polled every NFL fan who was not a TN Vol or Colt fan Brady or Montana would be the GOAT by a landslide. Not even close. I think Peyton is just as good as them but it comes down to Super Bowls which also has lots to do with your coach and the talent around you. Based on pure talent Aaron Rodgers is the GOAT

 

[engineerVOL]

Derrick Henry isn’t human.

 

[tn88volfan]

I’m pretty tough but if I tried to tackle D Henry I would be in a body cast.

 

[Weezer]

Brady or Montana is the GOAT. No debating that as much as I love Peyton Manning as a QB

Vol card revoked. Someone call security to escort this man from the building.

 

[revjayp]

Freakin Henry. Oh my.

 

[Shuler21]

Brady is very good---one of the best---, but to say he's better than Peyton based on rings is ignorant and uninformed. Peyton is a better QB---MVP trophies suggest as much. He won a Super Bowl with two different teams. When Peyton was on the field, he was the OC. He was the best at adjusting and making the right audible call. Early in his career, he had no defense to speak of in Indy. Then, the defense came in both Indy and Denver, and the Super Bowl rings followed. Brady has had continuity and stability throughout his career. He's been with Belichick throughout. I think Brady is one of the best but I can't just give him the label of the GOAT because of the rings. Football is a team sport. I think Marino, Elway, and Peyton are better than Brady in my lifetime. I know that's probably an unpopular opinion but they all looked to be better overall.

 

[MoCo_Vol]

Remove the Orange Colored Glasses. If u polled every NFL fan who was not a TN Vol or Colt fan Brady or Montana would be the GOAT by a landslide. Not even close. I think Peyton is just as good as them but it comes down to Super Bowls which also has lots to do with your coach and the talent around you. Based on pure talent Aaron Rodgers is the GOAT

Bradshaw has 4 rings, why isn’t he in the debate?

Honestly you stack it up with no names associated, it’ll be Brees, Brady or Manning. If you remove SB wins I’d be shocked if Brady pulled majority votes.

 

[Bearwallow Bandit]

Remove the Orange Colored Glasses. If u polled every NFL fan who was not a TN Vol or Colt fan Brady or Montana would be the GOAT by a landslide. Not even close. I think Peyton is just as good as them but it comes down to Super Bowls which also has lots to do with your coach and the talent around you. Based on pure talent Aaron Rodgers is the GOAT

I think Rodgers is one of the best of all time. Now that’s a dude who other than this year has never had a defense. Elite arm and insanely accurate. He’s decently mobile as well.