SugarCC
Gntlmen, u cant fight here, this is the war room!
- Joined
- Jul 29, 2018
- Messages
- 9,069
- Likes
- 43,491
I'm 40. I watched his entire career. From his first time getting some game action against UCLA in 94 all the way through his NFL career. He is the greatest all time QB to ever play at UT....there's no doubt about it. I also never said he wasn't talented because he wouldn't have had the career that he ended up having i he wasn't. All I said was what made him so great was his football IQ...and if you ask defensive players that lined up against him in college and the NFL they will say the exact same thing. He wasn't the most talented compared to other QBs but you could not outsmart him with schemes and such....the greatest football mind to ever play the QB position in my opinion.
I replied with my top 5 because the OP said talent and play making ability. When I think of play making ability...I think of making something out of nothing when your scrambling from a blitz and etc. So please don't act like I'm saying Manning is a scrub and not the GOAT.
I mean if we are talking about talent and play making ability then Manning should not be top 5. Hate to say it but the reason he was so good was because of his high IQ on the field not his physical attributes. Now going off talent and play making ability.....
Then it's gotta be in no order :
Hooker
Holloway
Shuler
Robinson
Dobbs