Hey everyone, thanks for all the advice. A good amount of it was put to good use.
We just got back today. I bumped the post above to remind everyone of the schedule we were on, and we stuck to it pretty well. Here's my rundown:
I will start with this: we completely underestimated the sheer magnitude of Magic Kingdom. That place is just absolutely stunning. We spent about 9 hours there, but we should have done a full day. My favorite ride there was honestly probably Space Mtn.
Hollywood Studios was good. Tower of Terror and Rockin' Rolller Coaster were legit. I enjoyed the Star Wars stuff the most though. It's a half-day park for sure. We combined it and MK into one day. We ended up doing 16.5 hours of parks that day.
What can I say about Epcot? Just an absolutely incredible place. "Soarin'" was closed so we did Test Track 3 times. Great ride. We're not big drinkers, but we did snacks around the world. That was rough by the time we got to America. Mexico was easily the best country, but we did the attraction at all of them (some were slow rides, some were movies, etc.) We spent just over 14 hours at Epcot.
We loved Animal Kingdom but we're also huge animal people. Everest is a terrific ride, and we rode the safari twice. The Tree of Life is one of the most incredible things I've ever seen in person.
On our rest day we rode the monorail just to see the parks. It was fun. We ended up going to Disney Springs (formerly Downtown Disney) and seeing Deadpool. Much much much needed rest day because my entire lower half was just in pure pain from the waist down.
This brings me to the Universal Parks. Universal and IoA are cool, but nothing compares to the Harry Potter parks. Diagon Alley was Day 1 (Universal) and it is the most visually stunning place I've ever been, and it is EXTREMELY accurate based on the movies. The first thing we did was go to Ollivander's and buy our interactive wands so we could interact with things at the park. Then we went on the Gringotts ride where the goblins at the bank are eerily real. Great ride also. Then we drank butterbeer. We bought the fastpass and spent 10 hours at Universal, I would say about 6 hours of that was in Diagon Alley.
As for Islands of Adventure, we spent 12 hours there, and about 10 of it was in Hogsmeade. Several of the rides in IoA are closed for maintenence, the ones that are left are all pretty lame. There were more people in Hogsmeade than in the rest of the park. Hogwarts is the best place in either park. It has (in our opinion) the best ride of the entire vacation, which is Harry Potter's Forbidden Journey. We rode it 5 times, and did the walking tour of Hogwarts.
But enough about that. In regards to general places we went, here's my order, then I'll post a few pics, and yes I'm ranking the HP worlds as different parks.
1. Hogsmeade (because of Hogwarts)
2. Diagon Alley
3. Magic Kigdom
4. Epcot
5. Animal Kingdom
6. Universal
7. Hollywood Studios
8. Islands of Adventure