Peyton vs Berry??

[ihateflorida]

Which was respected more at the time they left UT? I say EB because people like to blame Peyton for Florida losses. I dont know of anything that we can blame EB for.

 

[YankeeVol]

Peyton

 

[Bassmanbruno]

well - Peyton returned for his senior year so probably your answer.

 

[Behuman13]

People shouldn't blame Peyton for Florida losses.
I respect Eric Berry more, probably because I wasn't watching Tennessee football when Peyton played.

 

[kngjabez]

Which was respected more at the time they left UT? I say EB because people like to blame Peyton for Florida losses. I dont know of anything that we can blame EB for.

Respected??? Berry

 

[Daddy Gee]

can we include fulmer in this vote? opcorn:

 

[chavisut]

How many games were won during Berry's tenure here at UT again? Yeah.....

 

[hunterab]

peyton

 

[BearCat204]

Peyton

 

[DEFENDTHISHOUSE]

In Peytons defense, he didn't play defense in those games against UF.
Posted via VolNation Mobile

 

[DEFENDTHISHOUSE]

In Peytons defense, he didn't play defense in those games against UF.
Berry will be a great pro.
Posted via VolNation Mobile

 

[lylsmorr]

Peyton.

 

[mkil5]

Peyton

 

[kngjabez]

few Respected Peyton during his tenure. They respected Leonard Little

 

[chavisut]

few Respected Peyton during his tenure. They respected Leonard Little

Silly.

 

[lylsmorr]

few Respected Peyton during his tenure. They respected Leonard Little

hmm, I think I see what you ar....wait, what????

 

[GAVol]

few Respected Peyton during his tenure. They respected Leonard Little

Negative

 

[vollygirl]

Eric has put more reasons on my list than Peyton did.
Posted via VolNation Mobile

 

[BJSforVols]

Peyton by a significant margin. Even if Peyton had not come back for his senior year, I think he would have been, but coming back for his senior season when most did not expect it turned Peyton into a saint on the hill.

 

[Behr]

Eric has put more reasons on my list than Peyton did.
Posted via VolNation Mobile

Really? I wouldn't have guessed that from you.

 

[vollygirl]

Really? I wouldn't have guessed that from you.

I didn't love Peyton like I do Eric. I was proud Peyton was on our team, but I was proud Eric was a Vol. Maybe it's because I know more about EB as a person than I did Peyton. Just my opinion.

 

[brookieV0L]

the most idiotic question, EVER.

So true, Why compare two amazing players?

 

[SamQB7]

peyton... hands down... no question about it.

 

[Incipient]

I didn't love Peyton like I do Eric. I was proud Peyton was on our team, but I was proud Eric was a Vol. Maybe it's because I know more about EB as a person than I did Peyton. Just my opinion.

I feel this way as well. I'd rather have Peyton as a player (because of the important position he plays), but Eric. . . wow. I'm just splitting it up into Favorite Offensive Vol and Favorite Defensive Vol. Can't choose just one.

 

[Sabanocchio]

Can't believe there's even a question here.