One game doesn't determine a coach's worth

#1

Biso

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 6, 2017
Messages
211
Likes
622
#1
I'm going to post this, then I'm going to duck for cover while y'all blast me. Listen, no one was more disappointed in yesterday's outcome than I was. I wasn't sold on Pruitt when Fulmer hired him, but I spent the last month convincing myself that Tennessee was going to give West Virginia a run for its money. We might not beat them, but we might...and we'd certainly cover the spread. To see Grier pass the ball so easily against our clueless secondary in the second half was frustrating. To know that your new head coach is a defensive mind and to come to the realization that your defense is subpar at every position and hardly improved from last season is disheartening. If I'm being honest, I'm a little less certain now than I was 24 hours ago that Pruitt can turn things around here. I've lowed my floor for this UT team from 4-8 to 3-9. I've gone from being confident the Vols will be bowl eligible this season to just hoping they will be.

But with all that said, I can't believe how many posts there are here from people who are ready to write Pruitt off completely after just one game as a head coach. C'mon, people. We don't know if Pruitt can be successful...but we also don't know that he can't be. He may turn out to be another Derek Dooley, or he may turn out to be another Kirby Smart. But we don't know after one game, we were never gonna know after one game, regardless of the outcome. For that matter, we won't know after the Florida game.

Can I just remind everyone that if a coach's worth was determined with one bad game, Nick Saban wouldn't have five national championships at Alabama because he would've never been allowed to coach beyond his first season. That 21-14 loss to Louisiana-Monroe in 2007 is probably the most inexplicable loss in his coaching career. And, yeah, there were plenty of Alabama fans who were ready to ride him out of Tuscaloosa on a rail after that game -- just like y'all are ready to tar and feather Pruitt now. I remember how the Tide boards melted down after that game. That was a ULM team that was nowhere near as talented as West Virginia (and that's obviously an understatement), it was an Alabama team that had more talent and more experience than this Tennessee team has, and it was not Saban's first game, which would've been a little more understandable...it was in November, after Alabama players had nearly an entire season under their belt as part of Saban's system.

Getting completely and thoroughly dominated by West Virginia sucks. But it isn't the end of the world and it's way too soon to think we can pass judgment on Pruitt as a coach.
 
#2
#2
But with all that said, I can't believe how many posts there are here from people who are ready to write Kiffin Dooley Jones Hoke Pruitt off completely after just one game as a head coach.
 
#3
#3
Yeah I agree it's one game. Everybody else played scrub opponents except us and Bama. Hopefully the players get some confidence these next two games, because we're going to need it against Florida.
 
#5
#5
OP has it wrong. One game does determine a coach's worth. It's all over, now, so you might as well forget the rest of the season and say bye bye.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bpalmer28
#6
#6
But with all that said, I can't believe how many posts there are here from people who are ready to write Kiffin Dooley Jones Hoke Pruitt off completely after just one game as a head coach.

And because those guys failed, Pruitt is automatically destined to fail as well? I mean, I get it...everybody is disillusioned. I am too. That's why I'm not going to buy in on Pruitt like I did Dooley and Jones until he proves it on the field. But I'm not going to write him off after one game, either. It's an exercise in futility. Sometimes we all get so passionate about this game of football that we need a good dose of perception. If our defense is still a hot mess and our OL is still tripping over their own feet when we're getting ready to go to Athens, then I'll change my tune. Until then, let's relax and enjoy the beatdowns of ETSU and UTEP.
 
#10
#10
But with all that said, I can't believe how many posts there are here from people who are ready to write Kiffin Dooley Jones Hoke Pruitt off completely after just one game as a head coach.

who was writing off kiffin, dooley, and jones after their first game? they all 3 won by a combined score of 158-7.
 
#11
#11
Can't turn water into wine our talent level is down folks. What I personally want to see is week to week improvements. Our program has been rebuilding for 10 years because they didn't hire the right guy. JUST A LITTLE MORE PATIENCE
 
#12
#12
All Tennessee fans can possibly do is WAIT and see how this season and next season turns out. We can b!tch all we want, but Pruitt will receive at least three seasons to make UT a 10 win team again.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NCVOL327
#13
#13
I'm not seeing many who are wanting to write him off completely. If so, they're irrational. What I am seeing is frustration in seeing a 10 point spread almost tripled. And a defensive head coach getting his defense OWNED in ALL areas
 
#15
#15
Saban lost to La Monroe his first year at Bama and Kirby got blown out by an awful Ole Miss team his 1st yr......
 
#16
#16
Saban lost to La Monroe his first year at Bama and Kirby got blown out by an awful Ole Miss team his 1st yr......

Don't do this. Cherry pick a stat or two to prove your point without telling the whole story. Kirby also beat a ranked UNC team the first game. Saban crushed TN his first year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LocoVol
#17
#17
Yeah I agree it's one game. Everybody else played scrub opponents except us and Bama. Hopefully the players get some confidence these next two games, because we're going to need it against Florida.
Agree...I guess I would probably rather eat humble pie right out of the gate so we don't get any delusions of grandeur, than playing cup cakes rolling into Florida game without a real test. Now, we are affirmed in our weaknesses and have a few weeks to address them... or at least that's what I'm thinking, while still wearing my orange colored glasses.
 
Advertisement



Back
Top