It's not legend only; it really happened. My dad played at UT '71-'75, and though he wasn't there when it happened, he did see a picture(s) of the "before" and "after", in addition to everyone (teammates mostly, and CBB) confirming the story. I'm sure some may call BS, and I guess that's fair, but if I was making it up, I'd say he saw him do it or at least was teammates w/him. I realize this doesn't prove anything, but figured some may have similar stories - I know there are some alumni who post on here every once in a while.
I think what OrangeByBirth is referring to is when Reynolds showed up to a pre-SB media session with handouts explaining how he got the nickname; that may have been construed as fiction.
Correct on all counts. I saw a reference yesterday to the fact that Reynolds dispensed "handouts" prior to the Super Bowl media sessions simply because he was sick and tired of answering the same question over and over and over. Here is one account of the hacksaw incident, which was originally published by Mike Strange in 2006:
"There must be something therapeutic about sawing," the stout man said with a chuckle. If the category is University of Tennessee football legends, any true Vols fan could identify the speaker. At 58, Jack "Hacksaw" Reynolds . . . was back in town Thursday, once again performing surgery on an old car. This time he's getting paid for it rather than venting frustrations. Thursday's sawing was a promotional appearance for LENOX, a manufacturer of tools and saws.
In November 1969, it was a grimmer scene. It was Reynolds' senior year and the unbeaten, third-ranked Vols were embarrassed 38-0 by Archie Manning and Ole Miss in Jackson, Miss. "I came back to school and I was very upset," Reynolds said. "I had to do something to relieve my frustration." Nothing spelled relief to Reynolds like sawing. He vented on a 1953 Chevrolet Bel Air that had been abandoned on a wooded hillside across the river from campus. . . . Reynolds purchased a pack of hacksaw blades on Kingston Pike and went to work on Sunday afternoon. He finished sometime Monday, 13 blades later. "I was going to cut it in half and make a trailer," he said. "That was some hard steel. You cant cut through a car with a hacksaw unless you cut it three or four times. I was breaking blades like crazy."
The next day, Reynolds and some teammates returned to admire his handiwork and got a surprise. "Lo and behold, somebody had stolen both halves," Reynolds said.
"All that was there was the logs I had it propped up on, the broken blades and the pieces of metal broke off the car." The masterpiece may have been gone, but Reynolds had a nickname for life.
After 15 seasons [in the NFL,] he retired in 84. He divides his time between homes in the Bahamas and Miami.
"I have all kinds of saws," he said. "There's something about sawing. I always said I was a cut above the other guys" (
DuckSouth.com • View topic - the mule game- (football) and the making of hacksaw jim.).