Can anyone separate from the pack?
www.rockytoptalk.com
Pretty good summary of the WR battle headed into practice monday. Cant wait to see Fingers reports. Its a rite of passage at this point.
I think people will be surprised at Braylon Edwards. I dont expect him OR Matthews to do much this season barring injuries we really don't want to see...but Edwards is the 78th ranked recruit at any position for a reason. You can go watch his HS film and he is absolutely dominant. Big body kid too. I think he will contribute down the road...but look at Nathan Leacock as a cautionary tale. Leacock was ranked 75th out of HS 2 years ago. He is 6ft4ish and fast. He dropped too many balls in practice and was redshirted last season while Webb and Nimrod (same class) both got to play due to injuries to Bru etc.
Matthews is a 5* kid but hes a slot WR in college. So he would have to beat out Squirrel White to start or get much playing time...and Squirrel has BY FAR the best hands on our team, and is the fastest player at UT until somebody proves different also. Squirrel had 8 catches on 8 targets from sloppy Milton in the 1st half vs Bama for example. In the 2nd half they rolled a nickel/safety toward him nearly every snap and shut him down. I dont think Matthews can beat him out for starting slot WR as a freshman, 5* or not. We will see i guess. Matthews is 3 or 4 inches taller and 25lbs or so heavier though...
As for Staley, theres a log jam outside for the starting spot opposite Bru assuming Bru comes back 100% in the fall. He wont play in spring though...so Nimrod, Webb, Leacock, and Staley will get a million reps outside this spring to show what they can do. Based on snaps played last season/production, the order i listed their names in above is the pecking order going into the spring. The wildcard is Brazzell from Tulane which we brought in in the offseason. His 700+ yards and 5TDs last year are far more than Nimrod and Webb managed combined...more than 3x their combined yards and TDs but he had far more snaps too. He is the big question mark in my mind for spring. Seems like if the Coaches felt great about Nimrod, Webb, Leacock then they wouldn't have spent all the time and $$$ to make sure we got Brazzell. How much of the lack of production by those 3 WR was Miltons inaccuracy...and how much was those guys not being able to get open outside vs SEC corners??? We can all remember Squirrel streaking wide open downfield repeatedly and Milton overthrowing him by 5 yards or more despite Squirrels speed...but the other 3 guys? Leacock didnt play at all, but I dont remember Nimrod and Webb running open downfield much. Hopefully Coach Pope and the strength coach has those guys faster, stronger, and running cleaner routes this year.
It will also be interesting to see if Matthews gets reps outside when/if he is unable to unseat Squirrel at starter in the slot. Coaches find ways to get the best playmakers on the field...and 5* kids might not stay at a school these days if they sit the bench all year. Matthews was dominant at the HS all star game though in Hawaii this offseason. Playing against the very best players in his class. He had 2TDs and looked great. Maybe I am wrong about him and he comes in and beats out White as a freshman. I wouldn't bet on it though. White was by far our most productive WR last season...and left a LOT of yards AND TDs on the field because of Milton. He has been beating out bigger and higher rated guys his entire career. We will see I guess. GO VOLS