West Columbia Gamecock
Gamecock Ambassador
- Joined
- Jul 30, 2004
- Messages
- 844
- Likes
- 0
WCG, since I know where you live . . . step in here and bring a little sanity. You've seen both guys in person multiple times. Who is better?
This is exactly what I think. Sidney Rice was an unbelievable receiver at a school that could count on one hand in its history the receivers that were as good as him. He does things on the field that are difficult to measure. His 40 time was not bad. His route running is exceptional. The way he uses his body to catch balls and shield defenders is amazing.
Robert Meacham is also a great player. He has a lot of the tangibles that the scouts like, such as a good 40 time, etc.
I think only time will tell as to who is better. I don't think one player is head and shoulders better than the other. This discussion should be brought up again in about 2 years.
This is Vol Board. It's two hours past my bed time. So my answer for you GAVol is...............SIDNEY FREAKING RICE!!!!:neener: