1 Sun January 16, 2000 L Indianapolis Colts Tennessee Titans 16 19 boxscore
2 Sat December 30, 2000 L Indianapolis Colts @ Miami Dolphins 17 23 boxscore
3 Sat January 4, 2003 L Indianapolis Colts @ New York Jets 0 41 boxscore
4 Sun January 4, 2004 W Indianapolis Colts Denver Broncos 41 10 boxscore
5 Sun January 11, 2004 W Indianapolis Colts @ Kansas City Chiefs 38 31 boxscore
6 Sun January 18, 2004 L Indianapolis Colts @ New England Patriots 14 24 boxscore
7 Sun January 9, 2005 W Indianapolis Colts Denver Broncos 49 24 boxscore
8 Sun January 16, 2005 L Indianapolis Colts @ New England Patriots 3 20 boxscore
9 Sun January 15, 2006 L Indianapolis Colts Pittsburgh Steelers 18 21 boxscore
10 Sat January 6, 2007 W Indianapolis Colts Kansas City Chiefs 23 8 boxscore
11 Sat January 13, 2007 W Indianapolis Colts @ Baltimore Ravens 15 6 boxscore
12 Sun January 21, 2007 W Indianapolis Colts New England Patriots 38 34 boxscore
13 Sun February 4, 2007 W Indianapolis Colts N Chicago Bears 29 17 boxscore
14 Sun January 13, 2008 L Indianapolis Colts San Diego Chargers 24 28 boxscore
15 Sat January 3, 2009 L Indianapolis Colts @ San Diego Chargers 17 23 boxscore
16 Sat January 16, 2010 W Indianapolis Colts Baltimore Ravens 20 3 boxscore
17 Sun January 24, 2010 W Indianapolis Colts New York Jets 30 17 boxscore
18 Sun February 7, 2010 L Indianapolis Colts N New Orleans Saints 17 31 boxscore
19 Sat January 8, 2011 L Indianapolis Colts New York Jets 16 17 boxscore
20 Sat January 12, 2013 L Denver Broncos Baltimore Ravens 35 38 boxscore
21 Sun January 12, 2014 W Denver Broncos San Diego Chargers 24 17 boxscore
22 Sun January 19, 2014 W Denver Broncos New England Patriots 26 16 boxscore
23 Sun February 2, 2014 L Denver Broncos N Seattle Seahawks 8 43 boxscore
24 Sun January 11, 2015 L Denver Broncos Indianapolis Colts 13 24 boxscore
25 January 17, 2016 W Denver Broncos Pittsburgh Steelers 23 16 boxscore
26 January 24, 2016 W Denver Broncos New England Patriots 20 18 boxscore
all playoff games started at QB by Peyton Manning (13-13)