RE Middleton: Nobody is going to come into a game cold and start shooting--not when you're playing, what, minutes a game? Players need confidence--all of them--and you don't build confidence playing 8 minutes a game. Same is true for Dunbar. And you can see what a player might bring if you never play her, tho I realize coaches see a lot in practice.
Yes, Cooper is quicker than Middleton, but she did not have a very good year. She had 74 assists/97 turnovers for the season-that's (obviously) a negative A/TO ratio. She shot 36 percent for the season. In the final game--she had 0 assists and 5 turnovers?-Yes, Cooper can penetrate--but we faced zone defenses most of the year that are hard to penetrate, and that's a big reason why she was not effective. Was she a freshman, yes; does she have upside, we all hope so.
Middleton is a better shooter and passer than Cooper--and we need shooting. She certainly knows how to use the bounce pass more effectively than our other guards.She shot 38 percent for the year and had 41 assists/37 turnovers--positive A/TO ratio. You need shooters to beat a zone defense--and yet we had our best shooter, Dunbar, and one of out better shooters, Middleton, on the bench most of the year--instead playing Cooper, who is one of our worst shooters. I think the metrics people would say that is dumb.
Am I saying Middleton should start? No. Am I saying she played great this year? No. I'm saying what Piney is saying: She could have been better utilized this year. The truth is, we had yet another year of weak guard play--which has been an going problem. Reynolds was our only consistently decent guard in all facets of the game, and she's not exactly a star.
Dunbar, too, was poorly utilized. To leave your best shooter sitting all year on a team that struggled to shoot against zone defenses all year, and that was a bad 3-point shooting team all year, well, not smart. And I'm tired of hearing about Dunbar's defense--she hasn't even played enough to know whether she can play defense. And, besides, Warlick's obsession with defense is one of her problems. We have been losing games because our offense struggles.