No way. I have 1,000x more confidence in Jeremy Pruitt than I ever had in Butch or Dooley to be a complete and competent head football coach. I think Pruitt is still learning how to manage more than just defense. I think he is struggling with roster management and how to build an offense, but I think he has surrounded himself with a good (if not great) OC to help him do it. I think he is a little hesitant to let go of the reins a bit, and may need to do that in order to give Chaney more input, but again, that's all speculation.
I think Pruitt is a fantastic teacher and great at relating to his players. I get the feeling he genuinely cares about his guys. I think the reason that he has yet to make the permanent switch at QB is because he wants JG to do well so badly that he keeps giving him chance after chance. I think Pruitt believes in his heart that he can be a great quarterback, and just doesn't want to be the one to give up on him. And I hate that, and appreciate it at the same time. However, Pruitt will learn the business in time of having to do the hard things. It's easier to do so with grown men then it is to do with college kids. Benching Guarantano means that he is benching any chance he has (as slim as they were) of playing football again at the next level.
I think Pruitt has never had to be the one to say "I'm benching you," or, "It's probably best if you look for another program to transfer to." I think he has just always worked with what he has, and Saban or Fisher or Richt did the hard stuff. I feel like that's the thing that is holding him back right now. Maybe I'm way off. But it seems like Pruitt has a very soft spot for his players, protects them to no end, even to his (and maybe even the program's detriment). It's why Banks was allowed back. It's why recruits love him so much. He is going to be a father figure to these guys and care about them, and give them as many chances as he can, and not throw them out there until they're ready. And again, that is an inherently good thing. But it can also hinder you as a football coach who needs to play the best players.
Again, JMO. I absolutely think he is the right man for the job. He's just got to learn to make the hard decisions regarding players, and I think he will get there, but I think it is difficult for him as a guy who loves these kids.