EasternVol
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Nov 18, 2021
- Messages
- 11,298
- Likes
- 7,822
The jokes about the Italian Military (especially in WWII) are legion.I’m sure Israel is shaking in their boots.![]()
Do you believe Israel is doing everything they can to mitigate civilian casualties? I don’t, I believe they are being intentionally cruel, and so do people that have been on the ground there trying to deliver aid, including Israelis.I understand why you feel that way and yes it is HORRIBLE what the people in Gaza are going through.
But I think if you look at it through a historical lens; you have to see that that is what happens in every war throughout history.
Yes the civilians are largely innocent but their leadership has put them in that situation. It isn’t fair; but it is inevitable.
Why should we expect Israel to fight a war without civilian casualties when no other single nation in history has been able to do so.
This is München in 1945. WE did this.
View attachment 776904
Do you believe Israel is doing everything they can to mitigate civilian casualties? I don’t, I believe they are being unintentionally cruel, and so do people that have been on the ground there trying to deliver aid, including Israelis.
I do believe they are doing all they can. Especially in a densely populated urban environment. They are using precision munitions and warning residents ahead of strikes. If Israel wanted to be cruel and promote extra suffering they would be carpet bombing or using incendiaries.Do you believe Israel is doing everything they can to mitigate civilian casualties? I don’t, I believe they are being intentionally cruel, and so do people that have been on the ground there trying to deliver aid, including Israelis.
The bombing of Dresden was a terrible act of cruelty inflicted on (almost exclusively) civilians, as was the fire bombing of Tokyo. In hindsight, many decision-makers regretted this and it remains a stain on the reputation of the allied countries. Both acts were also committed against countries on relatively equal footing as the allies. Palestinians are not on equal footing and are being intentionally starved, dehumanized, and abused. Shame on anyone ok with it.I do believe they are doing all they can. Especially in a densely populated urban environment. They are using precision munitions and warning residents ahead of strikes. If Israel wanted to be cruel and promote extra suffering they would be carpet bombing or using incendiaries.
Like i sort of hinted above; you might want to look at civilian casualty rates in Japanese and German population centers in WWII. And those numbers were caused by U.S. and Britain largely. Two nations that I hope we can both agree were not out to deliberately cause suffering
That last sentence is just silly. Haven't you yourself commented on Churchill's desire to inflict suffering on the German population to break their morale?I do believe they are doing all they can. Especially in a densely populated urban environment. They are using precision munitions and warning residents ahead of strikes. If Israel wanted to be cruel and promote extra suffering they would be carpet bombing or using incendiaries.
Like i sort of hinted above; you might want to look at civilian casualty rates in Japanese and German population centers in WWII. And those numbers were caused by U.S. and Britain largely. Two nations that I hope we can both agree were not out to 1deliberately cause suffering
The bombing of Dresden was a terrible act of cruelty inflicted on (almost exclusively) civilians, as was the fire bombing of Tokyo. In hindsight, many decision-makers regretted this and it remains a stain on the reputation of the allied countries. Both acts were also committed against countries on relatively equal footing as the allies. Palestinians are not on equal footing and are being intentionally starved, dehumanized, and abused. Shame on anyone ok with it.
So let me see if I understand you correctly. Israel is not allowed to defend itself against anyone unless they are on equal footing?The bombing of Dresden was a terrible act of cruelty inflicted on (almost exclusively) civilians, as was the fire bombing of Tokyo. In hindsight, many decision-makers regretted this and it remains a stain on the reputation of the allied countries. Both acts were also committed against countries on relatively equal footing as the allies. Palestinians are not on equal footing and are being intentionally starved, dehumanized, and abused. Shame on anyone ok with it.
The numbers are in.The UN is a cancer, not because of this, but an organization that corrupt makes FIFA look fair and equitable. Let's not hold them up as a bastion of truth.