Israel vs Palestinians II

[Persian Vol]

Seems they’re making very strong statements for “assumptions”. Once again, they’re not investigators.

They have to be an investigator to know that the country that is bombing the other country is responsible for the patents coming through their door?

 

[Persian Vol]

You seem to be shocked that stoning Jews results in a violent response. Hard to take that as anything other condoning the action

You’re just saying words at this point.

 

[Vol8188]

They have to be an investigator to know that the country that is bombing the other country is responsible for the patents coming through their door?

That’s not even remotely true. The Islamic jihad rocket that hit the hospital parking lot being a prime example. There’s more just scary Jews firing weapons in Gaza.

 

[Vol8188]

You’re just saying words at this point.

Right. Just random words that happen to be specific to the topic you brought up. Clearly just completely random.

Why do you pretend to be shocked that stoning Jews results in a violent response?

 

[Persian Vol]

Right. Just random words that happen to be specific to the topic you brought up. Clearly just completely random.

Why do you pretend to be shocked that stoning Jews results in a violent response?

What exactly is your argument?

 

[Persian Vol]

That’s not even remotely true. The Islamic jihad rocket that hit the hospital parking lot being a prime example. There’s more just scary Jews firing weapons in Gaza.

If you look at that incident in isolation, your argument might hold. But it doesn’t exist in a vacuum, it’s surrounded by 50,000+ deaths and the complete devastation of Gaza at the hands of Israel, which overwhelmingly outweighs a single misfired rocket from 2023.

 

[Vol8188]

What exactly is your argument?

If you initiate a violent action, you’re likely to get a violent response

 

[Vol8188]

If you look at that incident in isolation, your argument might hold. But it doesn’t exist in a vacuum, it’s surrounded by 50,000+ deaths and the complete devastation of Gaza at the hands of Israel, which overwhelmingly outweighs a single misfired rocket from 2023.

No one said it exists in a vacuum. But rather that both sides fire ordinances and Hamas even intentionally kills their own on occasion. For doctors pretend they know who harmed their patients, is a joke

 

[Persian Vol]

If you initiate a violent action, you’re likely to get a violent response

No no. In the scope of this situation. You are asserting that Hamas stoned Jews, and that Israel is justified to murder as many citizens (collateral or not)? Do I have that right?

 

[Persian Vol]

No one said it exists in a vacuum. But rather that both sides fire ordinances and Hamas even intentionally kills their own on occasion. For doctors pretend they know who harmed their patients, is a joke

The overwhelmingly majority of victims in Gaza are from Israel whether you see it or not. So yes, the doctors are in fact right to presume that the deaths are coming from Israeli forces.

If only there was a way to not have to speculate and allow independent journalists in Gaza…

 

[Smokey123]

No no. In the scope of this situation. You are asserting that Hamas stoned Jews, and that Israel is justified to murder as many citizens (collateral or not)? Do I have that right?

I think he’s saying the ones that threw stones/rocks were “stoning Jews” and were met with a justified response

 

[Persian Vol]

I think he’s saying the ones that threw stones/rocks were “stoning Jews” and were met with a justified response

I hope not, because that sounds even more ridiculous.

 

[MAD]

Egypt to invest $400m in Israel gas pipeline​

Egypt to invest $400m in Israel gas pipeline

en.globes.co.il

Following the huge $35 billion gas deal between Leviathan Partners and Egypt, and preparations for approval of the Nitzana pipeline in Israel, which will allow for increased exports, Egypt has approved the construction of the pipeline from its side, at an investment of $400 million, Saudi London-based newspaper Asharq Business has reported.

 

[Vol8188]

No no. In the scope of this situation. You are asserting that Hamas stoned Jews, and that Israel is justified to murder as many citizens (collateral or not)? Do I have that right?

Now you’ve completely lost me.

 

[Vol8188]

The overwhelmingly majority of victims in Gaza are from Israel whether you see it or not. So yes, the doctors are in fact right to presume that the deaths are coming from Israeli forces.

If only there was a way to not have to speculate and allow independent journalists in Gaza…

They’re allowed in.

 

[Vol8188]

I hope not, because that sounds even more ridiculous.

And now we are back to this

“Why can’t I stone Jews?”-this board right now

 

[MAD]

 

[Orangeslice13]

Comparing children throwing rocks in protest of occupation under an apartheid state (and subsequently getting sniped) to adolescent shootings is certainly a take.

You realize that after people died from being hit by rocks, Israel announced that throwing rocks would be met with lethal force.

And you have the nerve to act surprised when people are shot for it. Strange

 

[Persian Vol]

You realize that after people died from being hit by rocks, Israel announced that throwing rocks would be met with lethal force.

And you have the nerve to act surprised when people are shot for it. Strange

Sure, rocks can injure and in rare cases kill. But using that as blanket justification for live rounds against teenagers is the definition of disproportionate. One side has rifles, drones, and airstrikes; the other has stones. Calling that “self-defense” ignores the massive power imbalance and why those kids are throwing rocks in the first place.

 

[Persian Vol]

They’re allowed in.

The sky is also red.

 

[MAD]

 

[Orangeslice13]

Sure, rocks can injure and in rare cases kill. But using that as blanket justification for live rounds against teenagers is the definition of disproportionate. One side has rifles, drones, and airstrikes; the other has stones. Calling that “self-defense” ignores the massive power imbalance and why those kids are throwing rocks in the first place.

I may be smarter than you because of the authorities with guns say “we’re done with this, if you throw rocks we’re going to shoot you “ then I’m not throwing rocks and I’m making damn sure my kids don’t either

 

[Orangeslice13]

I think he’s saying the ones that threw stones/rocks were “stoning Jews” and were met with a justified response

Israel has clearly warned Errbody that if you throw stones you get shot.

It’s stupid to throw rocks and complain about being shot …..when you’ve been warned

 

[Orangeslice13]

They have to be an investigator to know that the country that is bombing the other country is responsible for the patents coming through their door?

So Hamas shooting all those women and children trying to leave the war zone……

 

[MAD]