I agree with most everything you post but I won't diminish anything about Chuck or Jamal. The fact Jamal was able to rehab his injury and preform at the highest level doesn't diminish in any way what Chuck was. The season Chuck had in 1989 is special in many ways. First until the Alabama game Chuck was Reggie Cobbs back up. Jamal didn't have that his freshman or sophomore year before his injury. Don't berate players by saying that clearly you're subjective opinion is valid because someone did something in the NFL. That would be like saying T Martin was a better college quarterback than Peyton Manning (which is clearly not the case) because he happened to win the national championship. People who saw both play can see so many similarities. Outside of Chuck being 5/8 5/9 they were very much the same backs. Powerful guys who could take it to the house every play.
I have said this before and I still am of the opinion if Chuck Webb doesn't blow his knee out in 1990 Tennessee probably has a very good chance to win the national championship.
Glad we had both of them and long for the time when we have another similar back to either one of them.
Go Vols