If you took the best players….

[wmcovol]

He's in the Hall of Fame because of his Broadway Joe brand. His stats are pretty crappy relative to HOF expectations.

Agree somewhat but you can’t compare stats of different rules eras. It was a completely different game then than today. Coaches would call a deep ball on 3rd & long & figure an “interception was as good as a punt” instead of checking down to a 4 yd completion. Defenses could grab & push WRs anywhere so long as the ball wasn’t in the air. OL had to block WITHOUT using their hands. And QBs were not protected in the least.

 

[Savannahbayvol]

Bart?

Bart and the Tide went 0-10 his senior year. One of my favorite NFL players but he was more a system qb.

Tide qb I would take would be Stabler

 

[NighthawkVol]

Bart and the Tide went 0-10 his senior year. One of my favorite NFL players but he was more a system qb.

Tide qb I would take would be Stabler

Agree. I’d probably take Richard Scott over Starr, TBH.

But based on NFL career, it’s Stabler and Hurts as the top 2.

 

[SalVolinus]

Hard to beat a stacked mountaineers

Lmao well done.

 

[PEPPERJAX]

Pitt would also have a crazy good all-time team.

Marino at QB, Dorsett and Curtis Martin at RB (Craig Hayward and LeSean McCoy too). Larry Fitzgerald at one WR spot. Ditka at TE. Russ Grimm.

Gastaneau, Ricky Jackson, Hugh Green, Aaron Donald, Chris Doleman, Darrelle Revis on defense.

They have something like 9 NFL hall of famers and Donald is certain to be inducted.

The All-Time Pitt NFL Team - Rick Gosselin

Dan Marino heads up Pitt's all-time NFL team

rickgosselin.com

Yeah
Pitt has produced some beasts over the years.

 

[Vol-e-ball]

Tennessee is not as strong at WR as most people think. LSU crushes us. Plus they have Burrow. Crazy good secondary.

 

[ZZ13]

Agree. I’d probably take Richard Scott over Starr, TBH.

But based on NFL career, it’s Stabler and Hurts as the top 2.

Is this Richard Scott the offspring of Richard Todd and Scott Hunter?

 

[LegionnaireOfTheMiserable]

Cool thread Neo!
This thread got me thinking about some of the greats Syracuse has produced since they are UT’s next opponent.
Jim Brown
Art Monk
Donovan McNabb
Marvin Harrison
Larry Csonka
Dwight Freeney
Etc

Syracuse and Pitt both would have very good teams for programs that are not consistent top 25 teams and haven’t been this century.

 

[207 others]

Lmao well done.

For me, it's the Mountaineers. Hard to beat a stacked Mountaineers.
(waits for ragebait)

 

[Ned Ray McWorkher]

We could compete with anyone on an all-time level. We wouldn't be ranked number 1, but I could see us around 8-10 if you're talking for sure.

 

[BernardKingGOAT]

Agree. I’d probably take Richard Scott over Starr, TBH.

But based on NFL career, it’s Stabler and Hurts as the top 2.

Do you mean Richard Todd

 

[SalVolinus]

For me, it's the Mountaineers. Hard to beat a stacked Mountaineers.
View attachment 762269(waits for ragebait) View attachment 762270View attachment 762267

I don't think WVU would even be top 40, but are people really just copy-pasting ChatGPT nonsense into message board posts now?

FYI it's probably not a great sign when your all-time greats were exposed in the NFL as scrubs. This ain't the Big Least.