The fact he can't win with all that talent makes it even worse since it was a young inexperienced UF team.
I agree with the OP and we should all reserve our coaching opinions to the end of the season. I am not a Doolaid drinker either but a supporter of the program.
OP is actually correct as are several others.
Where most on here FAIL is that they don't understand the process to totally rebuild a program and the player roster.
When CDD was the ONLY coach that would risk his career to come here we had the roster to play well.....against Memphis high school or the worst ACC teams...maybe.
College football is a 4 YEAR recruiting process just to try and get us back to where we can even compete well against the best SEC schools...4 YEAR folks.
Good SEC programs MUST have SEC type player in EVERY class from Seniors, Juniors, Sophs and Freshmen and then you have a full roster of SEC type player and you just reload every year to replace Seniors and Juniors that leave early for the NFL.
In year 1 CDD had to keep together the class of laMe kiffScum and he did that AND he added some other good players on his own.
CDD only has 2 recruiting classes of his own, Sophs and Freshmen so maybe you better look at some of those kids CDD brought in...
Brian Randolph...Potential all SEC and maybe All American.
McNeil...just a freshman but was all american coming out of high school with unlimited potential.
A J Johnson...Potential all American
Maggitt...Potential all American
Stone, Pig, McCullers, Sentimore, Couch, ect, ect, ect.
Kids that alaBummer and many other good programs tried to get BUT it was CDD that got them to Tennessee.
2 recruiting classes that are all on CDD and LOTS of really good SEC type of footVol players.
All in spite of everything being stacked against him and he's still recruited very well even with a lousy, losing team.
That IS progress and where we need it most...Real SEC type football players to get lots of WINS for our future.
CDD can't coach???
nick saTan kept CDD on his staff for 7 years and begged him to go to alaBubba with him and he says CDD is a **** good coach.
HOW can any of you armchair football experts say that CDD can't coach when he has NOT had enough SEC type players or the SEC type depth with any experience to even barely be able to compete with Vandy or a low level ACC team?
FACT is that if we fire CDD we will NOT get a proven, successful head coach to replace him because we simply do NOT have the money to pay enough for a HC to come here and risk their career.
FACT is that with a new HC the 4 YEAR recruiting process and learning curve starts all over again with a new O plan and a new D plan.
nick saTan walked into alaBummer with a real good roster of SEC type players on the roster to start off with...CDD walked into 1 of the worst football programs with a horrid roster that has to be totally rebuilt.
I HATE losing but I'm 58 years old and I do understand what it takes to totally rebuild an entire college football program from nothing and I HATE being patient too because I want a SEC and a National Championship right NOW too but that's simply not how college football works especially in the always tough SEC.
CSS will have our new D as a top 10 D but it will be next year and CDD and CSS deserve the chance to prove what they can really do once they have a full roster of their type of SEC type players to coach.
FloriDUHHHH beat us with 4* and 5* talent all over the field and on the bench for a solid 2 deep rotation that's been recruiting well for 10 years or more but our Tennessee Vols just don't have that type of talent everywhere...YET!
VFL...GBO!!!
actually without even knowing it you might have made a good point. Who knows what would have happened if Shula had been given another year or 2 in Bama. That is what I find hilarious. People keep comparing our coach to the right people for the wrong reasons. Shula was fired prematurely because fans had no patience and wanted a big name "proven" winner.Woo Hooo I can't wait to see what he does in another year when Bray, Hunter, and CP are gone. Face it folks, we have a Shula on our hands...Time to pony up and hire a real HC. That's what TENNESSEE needs. :furious3:
Will giving Dooley ten years to get us back in the top ten satisfy you guys? How about 20 years? Bama and the hogs turned their programs around in 2 years. Are their schools that much more desireable to top players than UT?
OP, it doesn't matter what you say, Vol Nation is going to be divided on this topic. I hope Dooley goes 8-1 or 7-2 the rest of the way to see what they'll say.
For the record, I have enjoyed having a little bit more hope from year to year under Dooley. I was very skeptical of the hire, and thought it was bad news for us. But here comes a guy from Louisiana Tech, taking over a no win situation. He has replenished the pantry to get us back to where we can at least be competitive. I thought he needed 4 years minimum with all of the problems that faced this team. This is only his 3rd season, and we've already drawn national attention and gotten Gameday.
I believed we would win Saturday, but I really underestimated Florida. Driskell played better than I would have dreamed he could, which also helped open up the run for Florida (although the lack of containment was inexcusable). The Gameday analysts didn't think we would win. They said defense and a running game would be the difference. Wouldn't you know they called it from a mile away. They are still impressed by us however, and we should be proud of our team too.
these people setting mattress factories aflame all have one thing in common... the exact opposite thing going on in your post. A complete and utter lack of logic. They want the team to win and win now, period. None of them can see or even have it explained to them that it is not possible.
No coach or coaching staff could turn this team around as fast as people want/expect. But Dooley has done an amazing job getting us on the path to recovery. If people would calm down and let the process complete we end up fine. Thing is that ain't gonna happen so all we can do is keep trying to open eyes and when people post moronic vitriol point out the flaws.
People love to point out Dooley's record....most other coaches put in his same position would have had a hard time doing much better but most fans are regular people and most people are complete and utter idiots who do not understand that the most dangerous thing is a "fact" used out of context.
Dooley is not the answer for Tennnessee Football.... Ohio State gets rid of one legend, and buys another. We get Dooley. What's wrong with this picture? I wish the guy luck, because I love the program. I think he's proved he can't beat a ranked team. His signature win is not Cinnci...his signature win is an overtime victory over Vandy. I think that says it all. I's not his fault though, it's Mike Hamilton's fault. Hamilton alone is the worst thing to ever happen to Tennessee sports. We as fans are gonna have to suck it up and see this for what it is. I'm not mad or sick or blaming the team....simply waiting for someone at this institution to make the RIGHT call.
Seriously... The bottom line is that Dooley's ceiling as a HC in the SEC is seven wins, maybe eight if things fall just right. It's been posted Ad Nauseum here but the biggest knock on him as UT's coach is 0-11 vs ranked teams. Has never won a game that the team trailed at halftime. Mental mistakes aplenty and a severe tendency to fold up at the first sign of adversity. Its been a recurring theme during his tenure here and I honestly don't see it getting any better. We will never beat a team we weren't supposed to beat with Dooley in charge and now we're losing to teams we shouldn't be losing to. All the folks saying "if you fire Dooley you're gonna set the program back another 2-5 years" don't want to see that keeping him around is doing exactly the same thing.
If you are talking about players quitting, I totally agree with you and the staff needs to make some changes. Some people say that character does not count but it sure does here.
are all the Dooley haters still gonna be talking when he wins 8 or 9 games this year?