I have no issues are all with hiring a coordinator. At the end of the day, the coach either has the it factor, or he does not. Yes, experience matters, football IQ matters, in-game awareness matters, but those are all secondary to the it factor.
Whether its sports, the business world, the military, politics or whatever, there are some people out there that are just plain gifted with the it factor. That is, the ability to connect with other people and own the room every time, all the time. When they speak, people buy in to what they are saying.
The truth is, you can find out just about anything you want to know about coaching football on the internet. And, there are countless books and videos out there. Every year, theres a coaching camp in every major city in the country. Just about anybody can fill their head with the knowledge of football. But, far fewer can actually instill that knowledge.
My son is a very accomplished pianist. I am continuously amazed by his talent. If you asked him, he would say he had a great teacher. And, he did. But if you speak with his teacher, his teacher would say I didnt teach him to play piano. I motivated him to teach himself.
Coaches with the it factor get 100% complete buy in from players from the time they are recruits until they play their last game as seniors. The team believes in the coachs message and sacrifices all to achieve it. He gets the most out of the guys he signs. Theyre all become self-motivated to achieve excellence.
Unless you hire a coach that has spent 5-6 years at the SAME place and has proven himself, you have no real idea if they have the it factor. Look at Jones. His first HC gig was three years. His second was as well. He never stuck around long enough for the bulk of the players to stop buying into his BS. At Tennessee, he did, and he was exposed.
Tennessee could have hired Leach or Miles. Maybe. I cant pretend to know the circumstances around that. The media may or may not have it right. But, short of those two, there was really no one reported to have interest that we could have any confidence in that they have the it factor.
So, you leave it up to the one doing the hiring to decide. Personally, I would have far more confidence in Fulmer to pick an effective leader than Currie. I believe Fulmer at least knows what a football coach is supposed to be.