Butch came in here saying things like he was going to bring in the best staff in America. He then hired almost all the coaches he had worked with at Cinci and gave them huge raises. His former OC left to be a QB coach. His former DC was fired (not for his poor performance, but for an off the field incident) and is a corner back's coach at a G5 school. He said he was shocked by all the top names that wanted to interview for the OC position, then hires a friend who had been out of coaching for years. He keeps ZA on staff and has promoted him even tho the WRs underperform every year and Butch even said he would work with them before UGA week. The OL has been horrible almost every year and the coach remains. He refuses to hire a good QB coach even tho that is arguably the most important position on the field.
He has blamed youth for the past 3 years and now that he can't use that excuse the team still looks weak and unprepared. He blames execution before admitting bad play calls. He has called out the people who said Worley was being used in a zone read offense even tho those people include former players and reporters who have covered cfb for years. He refuses to make in game adjustments on offense and has even said he doesn't make them. He goes into a conservative mode when he gets a lead leading to multiple losses.
He allowed a very questionable culture to exist in the football program. When he and the other coaches gave a press conference about the Title IX allegations he brought up how other coaches were using it against us in recruiting, which wasn't the time or the place for that. His high ranking recruiting classes were largely based on the number signed and not high individual rankings, we will see this more in the 2017 class since it has a ton of projects.
He reminds me of Ron Zook, a coach that is committed to his system even when proven that it doesn't work. Zook had ok/good years at UF but since he followed Spurrier they weren't good enough. Butch followed the worst coach in the history of UT so his ok looks good in comparison. If he had followed Fulmer then I honestly believe he would have been fired after 3 years.
I'm with you on the staffing, I had never heard of any of them until they were introduced and had to be told who he was(I thought he was the other Butch).
If you are referring to the alleged "rape" culture, it didn't exist, so nothing was allowed. The restraint he used, considering what he was being accused of was above average.
I respect his effort to redshirt JD, even tho it was a major blunder and put us a year behind.
The in game adjustments worked against us going conservative when he should have kept the pressure on the other team, both offense and defense(OU, Fl, and AR).
Youth and depth have been issues. This is the first year I would say we have stay fresh depth but not injury depth.
Like you said the jury is still out on recruiting.
I'm sure if offered the job back in 2009, we could be in better shape. He would not have ran off Boyd(I hope).
I'm still at a wait and see, next time we lose it's gonna get ugly, unless I get what I want and that's a 20+ win streak, then he may be ok after all.