I don't like Gundy, but I would have liked him as our coach. He coaches a very effective offensive attack and his defenses are above average most years. We love our coach and he hasn't delivered the above defense yet.
Courting Gundy was no different than those rumors after 2001 (probably planted by Fulmer and his agent) that he was being courted by other teams, both college and NFL). He was never going anywhere, but used the story to his advantage. Fulmer leveraged whomever was offering him a position to pad his nest in Knoxville.
I used to resent Gundy, but he was playing with a strong hand in the situations. His quotes from the article are very complimentary to UT and his respect for the program. His tweets made us look weak and foolish years ago, but he was just promoting himself and his football program. So screw him for that, but that is the price an AD and university pays when they court big time coaches. We aimed high and missed. He said Our admin made big package offers that were big time offers. I figured our offers were inadequate, but he does not imply that at all. We were just trying to get a coach in the catbird seat, and it wasn't happening.
I think Gundy would have won here and contended some years. Nothing I see from his teams makes me think differently. OkSt is the only B12 team I watch and his teams play like blue chippers when they are average at recruiting at best. That kind of coach could have made UT great again. We have that kind of coach now and I don't pine for Gundy. But the last decade would have been much more fun to watch if Gary Patterson or Mike Gundy had been the head coach. They are both legit great coaches and built great teams with cores of less than elite talent. They did it with real coaching and excellent gameday planning and players that were drilled to execute the plans very well.
And Gundy made OkSt a dangerous team to play that shouldn't even sniff the playoffs, but they are in the hunt regularly now. If he can lead OkSt to contend for the playoff, he could have been a winner in Knoxville. No doubt. He is getting to that point in his career where his assistant coaches are being poached and it will be harder to keep making homerun hires come to Stillwater. Fulmer reached that point and it only takes a few unsuccessful assistant hires to bring a team down a peg.
You say he would have failed here, but you are putting down a future College Football Hall of Fame coach. Bold move. How many other Hall of Fame coaches do you say would also fail at UT?