Gaffney's vs. PWill's

[tennesseeduke]

Here is the video comparison's.

Video of Jabar Gaffney's so called catch against UT in 2000. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-5611L20Mls

Video of PWills no catch. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mZm3ZODSJwc 25:43 mark of the vid.

You be the judge. Catch or No Catch on both?


Gaffney NO CATCH
P Wills CATCH
IMHO

:thud:

Tennesseeduke

 

[ih8danoles]

Gaffney = catch
Williams = no catch

JRM hit = targeting

 

[Biopsyman]

Phil caught it

 

[Remy]

Here is the video comparison's.

Video of Jabar Gaffney's so called catch against UT in 2000. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-5611L20Mls

Video of PWills no catch. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mZm3ZODSJwc 25:43 mark of the vid.

You be the judge. Catch or No Catch on both?


Gaffney NO CATCH
P Wills CATCH
IMHO

:thud:

Tennesseeduke

I just threw up in my mouth a little again watching the Gaffney video. I refuse to refer to it as a "catch."

 

[gobraves101035]

New rules=no catch 😞

 

[JFreak]

Remember that the definitions of a catch have changed drastically in the last 16 years.

 

[UneducatedGuess]

Here is the video comparison's.

Video of Jabar Gaffney's so called catch against UT in 2000. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-5611L20Mls

Video of PWills no catch. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mZm3ZODSJwc 25:43 mark of the vid.

You be the judge. Catch or No Catch on both?


Gaffney NO CATCH
P Wills CATCH
IMHO

:thud:

Tennesseeduke

P Wills plays in an era where a catch requires longer control.

Both are No Catches. Gaffneys is BS.

JRM shouldn't have been targeting or kick catch interference. Shoulder to helmet. No fair catch called. Bang bang play.

 

[Tin Man]

Williams did catch the ball, have complete possession if it with one foot down in the endzone. That's a TD. It does not matter that afterwards, he was knocked off balance and fell down, where the ground caused the ball to pop out. Bad call by the officials.

 

[Tin Man]

Gaffney = catch
Williams = no catch

JRM hit = targeting

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Another Gayduh fan trolling VolNation. May you suffer an itch you cannot scratch.

 

[Orange Alert]

Williams did catch the ball, have complete possession if it with one foot down in the endzone. That's a TD. It does not matter that afterwards, he was knocked off balance and fell down, where the ground caused the ball to pop out. Bad call by the officials.

According to the rules it wasn't a catch.

 

[JFreak]

Williams did catch the ball, have complete possession if it with one foot down in the endzone. That's a TD. It does not matter that afterwards, he was knocked off balance and fell down, where the ground caused the ball to pop out. Bad call by the officials.

You must keep possession through the ground. It was not a catch.

 

[Remy]

According to the rules it wasn't a catch.

It's like ball and strike calls in baseball, pretty much whatever they decide it is on any given play.

 

[Orange Alert]

JRM shouldn't have been targeting or kick catch interference. Shoulder to helmet. No fair catch called. Bang bang play.

The rule for targeting says:

RULES

Targeting and Initiating Contact With the Crown of the Helmet (Rule 9-1-3)

No player shall target and initiate contact against an opponent with the crown (top) of his helmet. When in question, it is a foul.

Targeting and Initiating Contact to Head or Neck Area of a Defenseless Player (Rule 9-1-4)

No player shall target and initiate contact to the head or neck area of a defenseless opponent with the helmet, forearm, fist, elbow or shoulder. When in question, it is a foul. (Rule 2-27-14)

Note: Beginning in 2013, ejection from the game is a part of the penalty for violation of both Rule 9-1-3 and Rule 9-1-4.

By rule the foul for targeting on JRM was correct. The rule makes no mention of intent or instances where the hit might be unavoidable, it either is or it is not.

 

[Grizzlymint]

P Wills plays in an era where a catch requires longer control.

Both are No Catches. Gaffneys is BS.

JRM shouldn't have been targeting or kick catch interference. Shoulder to helmet. No fair catch called. Bang bang play.

PWilliams knee hits the ground before the ball was even moving. Player is down and it should have been a catch.