For all the people calling for JG to replace QD

[9296potsguy]

Still feel like it's been a wise decision?


Or is Larry Scott a joke and it doesn't matter if Manning was the QB?

 

[Grudenator]

I said all along that JG stinks. 90% of his complete passes this year have been screen passes.

 

[GAVol]

Here's what I know. I'm looking at JG's floor and it looks an awful lot like QD's ceiling.

Once Dormady started turning it over, it's hard to justify not going with the young guy.

 

[GetYouSomeofThat]

Still feel like it's been a wise decision?


Or is Larry Scott a joke and it doesn't matter if Manning was the QB?

Is both an acceptable answer?

JG is probably a good kid but he is not even close to ready to play at this level.
Maybe on him, but likely just really SH.ty coaching from Canales and Scott.

I feel sorry for our poor defense..

 

[Remy]

Yes, since the start of the season QD played scared and was constantly looking around trying to find somebody to which to give his lunch money. Nice kid, lights came on and it was too much for him. JG is not playing scared. Dobbs as a frosh against Bama got beat but never played scared.

 

[DownTheField]

Eau contraire...we've been calling for JG to replace BJ

 

[Carl Pickens]

Still feel like it's been a wise decision?


Or is Larry Scott a joke and it doesn't matter if Manning was the QB?

Larry Scott is horrible ..... pathetic and I believe you and I couldn't do any worse.

 

[Vato]

Still feel like it's been a wise decision?


Or is Larry Scott a joke and it doesn't matter if Manning was the QB?

At least he can move in the pocket. QD sucks, the OC sucks, the HC sucks...

 

[GetYouSomeofThat]

Here's what I know. I'm looking at JG's floor and it looks an awful lot like QD's ceiling.

Right

QD led teams never scored either?

Geeze, JG is not able to compete at this level

 

[fossilfiction]

Still feel like it's been a wise decision?


Or is Larry Scott a joke and it doesn't matter if Manning was the QB?

Larry Scott is a big problem.

 

[armchair]

Here's what I know. I'm looking at JG's floor and it looks an awful lot like QD's ceiling.

We've got 100 yards of offense for the game. We have NO passing game with JG--unless you count an avg. of 2 yards a completion. We were terrible with Dormady--but better than this. Scott, meanwhile, clearly has NO IDEA what he's doing--I'm sure of that.

 

[Carl Pickens]

Is both an acceptable answer?

JG is probably a good kid but he is not even close to ready to play at this level.
Maybe on him, but likely just really SH.ty coaching from Canales and Scott.

I feel sorry for our poor defense..

The receivers can't get open at all.... so we really have no idea if JG is ready or not. ..... wtf is he supposed to do

 

[ManchesterV]

Most likely we would’ve beaten S.C. with Dormady, but it wouldn’t have mattered today. I support the decision though. This has probably kept JG at Tennessee and the new coach hopefully can develop him. He does have talent. It’s just early.

 

[MurphyVol]

JG looks decent to me. Good mobility, strong arm. Had some long passes dropped or just off fingertips. I think he'll be a good QB. Consider he has no blocking, coaching or receivers

 

[GetYouSomeofThat]

Yes, since the start of the season QD played scared and was constantly looking around trying to find somebody to which to give his lunch money. Nice kid, lights came on and it was too much for him. JG is not playing scared. Dobbs as a frosh against Bama got beat but never played scared.

You can't really believe JG is ahead of QD, can you?


WE HAVEN'T SCORED A TOUCHDOWN WITH JG.. Great kid. Has potential. NOT READY

 

[10NCVol88]

A JG led offense has 0 TDs. How is he better again? Because he can run? That hasnt even helped in this horrible offense.

 

[GAVol]

Right

QD led teams never scored either?

Geeze, JG is not able to compete at this level

I don't think either is very good, but the performance against UMASS and UGA was cause for alarm.

 

[nash101]

JG has potential but he’s not ready for prime time (and not as good as the original SNL cast)

Also Scott and Butches hurry up and punt offense are horrid as well. This is reason #1 why Butch should be replaced ASAP — he’s too stubborn to make or allow any changes to HIS offense.

If Peyton Manning were QB right now, he be remembered as for fondly as Dormady is — that’s on the coach being married to his scheme instead of adapting to the talent

 

[CoaxialOrange]

Doesn't matter were a bad football team

 

[GAVol]

Doesn't matter were a bad football team

agree...With o-line and WR play like this, the QB is almost an afterthought.

 

[TBrown33]

JG is the better option

 

[GetYouSomeofThat]

The receivers can't get open at all.... so we really have no idea if JG is ready or not. ..... wtf is he supposed to do

Ok I can agree with this

However Dormady was able to pass a little bit

 

[RollerVol]

this is not the JG that could be...anybody ever saw any of his HS footage...he's got potential, I see flashes now...coaching change could help him develop into a pretty damn good QB...IMHO...:twocents:

PS. playcalling could possibly help also...

GO VOLS!

 

[Carl Pickens]

We've got 100 yards of offense for the game. We have NO passing game with JG--unless you count an avg. of 2 yards a completion. We were terrible with Dormady--but better than this. Scott, meanwhile, clearly has NO IDEA what he's doing--I'm sure of that.

Scott is the most incompetent OC I think I've ever seen. His play calling had no logical progression at all. It's as if he reaches into a bag and pulls out a play and runs it....he sucks

 

[Carl Pickens]

Ok I can agree with this

However Dormady was able to pass a little bit

True..... it's debatable which is the best option at this point..... one isn't very good and the other one isn't all bad