This has been a debate amongst Gator Nation for about 4 years now. Franks was starting mostly because of his experience. Trask has had two really untimely injuries in his career that set his development back, he broke a finger as a Freshman and he broke a foot last year. The injury as a Freshman gave Franks all of those game reps at a very young age. So then, even as the two appeared to be very close, Franks was getting the nod based off game experience, and that kept building on itself.
Another thing is, Franks is NOT the type of QB to look bad in practices, in fact, he’s mesmerizing in practice. I’ve been to several and witnessed this, the guy is a practice phenom. The weakness in his game has always been between the ears and the things he struggles with are very hard to replicate in practices; he can’t be hit, he can’t truly feel pressure, etc.
So it has been hard to hand Trask the job, all things considered. It’ll be fascinating to see how he does, I’m looking forward to it.