I am glad they brought the game back even though it took me a while to get in it. Definitely has its fair share of flaws but it was the first version and it didn't feel like a Madden copy&paste which is a big win.
My biggest gripes:
1. Attribute scaling. There shouldn't be 10 players on my roster with 99 speed/acceleration or even more than 1 tbh. Even scenarios when your Olineman has 90 speed.
2. Insane interceptions by their players. Luckily you can tune sliders to help but typically a DE shouldn't be making Manuel Neuer-esque no look dives intercepting the ball.
3. Simming in dynasty is awful. Your 93 overall team going 6-6, losing to the likes of Kennesaw State.
I don't have a lot of faith in EA but hopefully they keep listening to us and work on making the product better ...but they prob won't.