A disappointing finish to the most excellent and exciting year of Panthers football. Congratulations are in order to both Denver and Peyton Manning. With either a Panthers' or a Broncos' win, it was going to be bittersweet.
Here are my top 10 thoughts on the game and related material:
1. While I do not think it is the reason the Panthers lost, that early blown call with the Cotchery catch led to a series of event from which it was hard to recover.
2. Speaking of that Cotchery catch, the NFL really needs to modify its written rules over the offseason to finally clearly define what is a catch. The game refs seemed to think a "catch" is made with the hands, while the CBS guys and their official commentator seemed to think a "catch" is simply establishing control of the ball, which Cotchery clearly did. Regardless, this is a mess, and the NFL needs its refs to have a more unified understanding of what does and does not constitute a "catch."
3. I figured Denver would have to win the turnover battle to have a shot, and I was right.
4. Denver's defense is one of the best I've ever seen. It rivals some of those great Ravens' defenses from the early '00s.
5. Lost in the shuffle and especially due to Denver's defensive performance (which was obviously more difficult having to go against Carolina's offense) was the nearly equally great performance by Carolina's defense. Vonn Miller won Game MVP, and rightfully so, but he actually wasn't even the best defensive player on the field last night, statistically. That would have been Carolina's Ealy, with his three sacks, one forced fumble, one fumble recovery, and one interception. Probably the greatest defensive stats of a player in the Super Bowl in some time.
6. Watching the game, it felt as if Denver completely dominated the action, and, to be fair, Denver certainly did set the tone and the pace. However, a look at the statistics reveals a game that was actually much closer than it appeared. In fact, if you were to just look at the stats (with no score reference) you may be inclined to think that the Panthers won. The defensive performances were pretty much a draw, and the Panthers' offense outperformed Denver's statistically (not that that's saying anything). So, given that the game was in reality very even, what made the difference? That would be my 7th and 8th points.
7. Special teams helped Denver greatly, whether it was field position, a missed Carolina FG, or that wacky botched punt coverage. (About that punt coverage, I don't think I've ever seen anything so wacky on a punt. It's almost like all the Panthers' coverage guys thought he couldn't possibly have not fair-catched, so they didn't even bother to tackle him).
8. But here's the biggest difference: where the turnovers occurred. The biggest difference in that game was not necessarily the Denver defense or even the turnover margin - it was where the turnovers occurred on the field. Both teams had their share of turnovers, yet Denver's primarily occurred in spots where it did not hurt them as much, while Carolina's often occurred deep in their own territory. When Denver forced a Carolina turnover, its offense usually didn't really even have to drive the ball much for at least three points, and, of course, the recovery of the fumble in the endzone early on is self-explanatory.
9. Cam Newton is a young guy, and I'm not going to rip him too much, but he really needs to make a commitment to get his act together during the offseason. The idea that a franchise QB would go before the media minutes after a Super Bowl loss with a damn hoodie on and sulk is just ridiculous.
10. The Panthers had plenty of opportunities, and, despite Denver's great D, I saw wide open Carolina receivers all night. The problem was not getting open; the problem was that Cam overthrew too much and, when he finally didn't overthrow (or underthrow for that matter), his receivers often dropped the ball. You can't win like that, especially against a team that good against the run.
Well, now to the silly season and a year of waiting. I am confident moving forward, because I think this team will have ample opportunities to make it back to this stage in the coming years. I anticipate us making SB runs for at least the next couple of seasons. It's possible the team can be even better next year, with Benjamin returning and with some smart free agency deals. We'll see.