I think Butch was capable of being successful longer term at CINCY.
It was more his level. Everyone says he rode Brian Kelly's coattail's, and he obviously did. But he also recruited well up there.
Tommy Tuberville went 9-4 in his first two seasons after Butch. So CBJ left the cupboard full for him.
His spiel can work at a mid-tier program facing mid-tier and below competition.
Look at the 2011 and 12 stats for those Bearcats teams. They had good offensive numbers and the defense was effective. We learned how capable Jancek was when he had to be replaced with someone that was supposed to be a huge upgrade.
Butch's nutrition and S&C ideas were good enough at CINCY. Butch was Big East COY in 2011. You know, he really did look like a good coach who could rise to a bigger job. Lord knows he really believes in his potential.
I bet ARKst would love to have Blake Anderson back. He was a winner there and tripped up once. and Butch has not improved the program at all and I imagine no coaching 'up and comers' want to "learn" under him.