In fairness I watched USC Trojans get boat raced by Notre Dame and Brian Kelly Saturday night using this same offense. The issue is the coaching and CBJ owns what is on the field lock, stock, and barrel. Not the players, not the administration, not the fans, not the media, just him and the staff he hired owns what is happening on the field.
Which is more likely?
The HC is a genius with an unbeatable scheme but every kid on the team is intellectually subnormal.
The HC is not very good at coaching.
If they cant be properly taught they wont succeed
True to a point. But think about it, are all these guys on UTs roster just 2 and 3* nobodies? I mean did they come from little tiny schools? No they did not. Many of these guys were highly recruited and rated guys. Now that means these players are supposed to have talent. Yes coaching is a big part of it but its not all of it. You can be the best coach in the world but if your guys dont execute, then you arent going to win.
Take Alabama last year losing to Clemson. What happened? Was it Sabans coaching that cost them the game? Was it Bama player execution failures? What about when Bama lost to Hugh Freeze? Was Freeze the better coach? Or was it Sabans players just screwed it up? All of you who assign zero blame to players are just flat out wrong.