Breaking Down the Two Deep: Running Backs

#1

UTGhostHunter

Amatuer Analyst
Joined
Jan 31, 2011
Messages
1,132
Likes
2
#1
The next part of the two deep breakdown is running back. First, let me say that I'm not including a fullback due to the current belief that the fullbacks will be utilized in more of a H-Back roll. Second, I'm going to work under the belief that the top three at the position are all even on the depth chart, basing this off of the post-spring depth chart released by the school. For this reason, the list is going to include four backs. Here we go!

Marlin Lane is a talented back who brings a balance of speed and strength. He has decent size at 6'0" and 205 pounds, and he has the speed to break big runs, as evidenced by his 45 yard season long run. He is also a talented receiver out of the backfield. He does a little of everything, totaling 620 all-purpose yards last season as a true freshman. Lane needs to develop his field vision, which can help to increase his yards per carry (3.7 in 2011). Lane also needs to add some weight, roughly 10-15 pounds, in order to help improve his ability to run up the middle. Lane should be used as option number one this season, but he absolutely can't carry the load alone.

Rajion Neal is option number two, and he is lightning out of the backfield. Well, he is when he's in the backfield. Neal found himself being utilized as an emergency wide receiver last season, and he performed well in that capacity. In fact, in his top performance Neal accumulated four receptions for 125 yards in the loss to Kentucky. Neal accounted for 403 total yards last season and has produced 700 total yards during his time on the Hill. Neal has sub-4.4 speed and is a nightmare in the open field, but he isn't a player who tends to run up the middle. He is also a straight-line runner who doesn't display a lot of wiggle. Neal has the size to run up the gut, but he needs to dedicate himself to learning to run with a low pad level.

Devrin Young is very intriguing. He is only 5'8", 171, he runs in the 4.4 range, and he is fearless, but none of those are his true strength. His greatest strength is his vision and quickness. Young will change direction quickly, finding the cut-back lanes and breaking ankles. He doesn't seem like a back that is capable of running it down a defense's throat, but the bold little back is more than willing to help pound the middle of the defense. While Tennessee has bigger and faster backs, none of the others have the same type of elusiveness that Devrin possesses. That elusiveness helps him to excel as a kick/punt returner. Concerns about durability have been risen, and in spite of his willingness to run it into the teeth of the defense he isn't difficult to take down once a defender lays hands on him. Young should be able to put on weight and get to 185-190, but until he does he won't be special running it between the tackles. Young looks like a player who can fill out to play at Dee Hart, Mike Hart, or Travis Stephen size while keeping his speed. Although Devrin is fast, he isn't as fast as some of the other backs, so he might be at risk of getting caught behind the line if he gets too fancy.

Tom Smith isn't the biggest, fastest, or strongest back on Tennessee's roster, but he might have one of the biggest hearts and strongest work ethics. Smith may remind some Tennessee fans of another recent Volunteer: Tauren Poole. Smith has many similar features to Poole, which suggests a lot of potential for Smith. Tom fancies himself a power runner, and he is certainly more comfortable when he's running between the tackles. Smith isn't likely to break many long runs. He also seems to lack the size for his running style, although Poole was certainly capable fourth back and short yardage option.

The receivers are next, so look for that within the next week!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 8 people
#2
#2
Only thing I see that needs to be added is Neal needs to hold on to the ball better. Will also be interesting to see if Bourque will be able to prove himself worthy of being on this list.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
#3
#3
Only thing I see that needs to be added is Neal needs to hold on to the ball better. Will also be interesting to see if Bourque will be able to prove himself worthy of being on this list.

I think that's a standing need for the entire group. As for Bourque, he has potential, but he does need to make sure he qualifies. Beyond that, he will have to learn the system quickly. I think he can help, but not before the Georgia game.
 
#5
#5
The next part of the two deep breakdown is running back. First, let me say that I'm not including a fullback due to the current belief that the fullbacks will be utilized in more of a H-Back roll. Second, I'm going to work under the belief that the top three at the position are all even on the depth chart, basing this off of the post-spring depth chart released by the school. For this reason, the list is going to include four backs. Here we go!

Marlin Lane is a talented back who brings a balance of speed and strength. He has decent size at 6'0" and 205 pounds, and he has the speed to break big runs, as evidenced by his 45 yard season long run. He is also a talented receiver out of the backfield. He does a little of everything, totaling 620 all-purpose yards last season as a true freshman. Lane needs to develop his field vision, which can help to increase his yards per carry (3.7 in 2011). Lane also needs to add some weight, roughly 10-15 pounds, in order to help improve his ability to run up the middle. Lane should be used as option number one this season, but he absolutely can't carry the load alone.

Rajion Neal is option number two, and he is lightning out of the backfield. Well, he is when he's in the backfield. Neal found himself being utilized as an emergency wide receiver last season, and he performed well in that capacity. In fact, in his top performance Neal accumulated four receptions for 125 yards in the loss to Kentucky. Neal accounted for 403 total yards last season and has produced 700 total yards during his time on the Hill. Neal has sub-4.4 speed and is a nightmare in the open field, but he isn't a player who tends to run up the middle. He is also a straight-line runner who doesn't display a lot of wiggle. Neal has the size to run up the gut, but he needs to dedicate himself to learning to run with a low pad level.

Devrin Young is very intriguing. He is only 5'8", 171, he runs in the 4.4 range, and he is fearless, but none of those are his true strength. His greatest strength is his vision and quickness. Young will change direction quickly, finding the cut-back lanes and breaking ankles. He doesn't seem like a back that is capable of running it down a defense's throat, but the bold little back is more than willing to help pound the middle of the defense. While Tennessee has bigger and faster backs, none of the others have the same type of elusiveness that Devrin possesses. That elusiveness helps him to excel as a kick/punt returner. Concerns about durability have been risen, and in spite of his willingness to run it into the teeth of the defense he isn't difficult to take down once a defender lays hands on him. Young should be able to put on weight and get to 185-190, but until he does he won't be special running it between the tackles. Young looks like a player who can fill out to play at Dee Hart, Mike Hart, or Travis Stephen size while keeping his speed. Although Devrin is fast, he isn't as fast as some of the other backs, so he might be at risk of getting caught behind the line if he gets too fancy.

Tom Smith isn't the biggest, fastest, or strongest back on Tennessee's roster, but he might have one of the biggest hearts and strongest work ethics. Smith may remind some Tennessee fans of another recent Volunteer: Tauren Poole. Smith has many similar features to Poole, which suggests a lot of potential for Smith. Tom fancies himself a power runner, and he is certainly more comfortable when he's running between the tackles. Smith isn't likely to break many long runs. He also seems to lack the size for his running style, although Poole was certainly capable fourth back and short yardage option.

The receivers are next, so look for that within the next week!



Not a compliment.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4 people
#7
#7
Not a compliment.

I'm comparing physical traits, and they share several in common. Nothing I've ever heard about Smith suggests he has any quit in him. I know Poole caught a lot of heat after the Kentucky game, but I think most Vol fans would be happy to see the kind of productivity Poole provided the last two years out of Tom.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
#8
#8
poole and smith are very different when it comes to football running styles. smith more like a henry build, all legs, runs low...just lacks reps and experience as of now.
 
#9
#9
poole and smith are very different when it comes to football running styles. smith more like a henry build, all legs, runs low...just lacks reps and experience as of now.

And Smith can actually get yards after contact, unlike Poole.
 
#11
#11
Thanks for the great info once again UTGhostHunter. Any insight on what sort of impact
the frosh backs like Bourque or others might have? I am very anxious to see how this unit comes togther, as I think it might be our most important.
 
#12
#12
It is obvious substantial effort was put into your analysis and I commend you for that. However, I would refrain from constantly making comparisons to other players as you have done in all of your analysis. It seems you are using a plug and chug model on each of the rb and QB analysis. Differentiate yourself by breaking the mold the recruiters, lemmings, steeles of the world use and try to establish your own voice. All constructive criticism so 100% on effort, just work on originality.
 
#13
#13
Thanks for the great info once again UTGhostHunter. Any insight on what sort of impact
the frosh backs like Bourque or others might have? I am very anxious to see how this unit comes togther, as I think it might be our most important.

I don't think the freshmen will make any impact until at least Georgia, unless the coaches use Hill for some extra size and length in short yardage. Bouque still needs to ensure he qualifies; the same for Watson. Then, since they're both enrolling in the second summer session, they'll need to absorb the playbook quickly. They seem like longshots to make much impact in the first month.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
#14
#14
It is obvious substantial effort was put into your analysis and I commend you for that. However, I would refrain from constantly making comparisons to other players as you have done in all of your analysis. It seems you are using a plug and chug model on each of the rb and QB analysis. Differentiate yourself by breaking the mold the recruiters, lemmings, steeles of the world use and try to establish your own voice. All constructive criticism so 100% on effort, just work on originality.

I appreciate the feedback. When I evaluate, I try to base my analysis off of what I see on video, what I see in the numbers, and what potential I see. It's the potential that leads me to draw comparisons. I appreciate the work of others, but I don't intentionally attempt to confine myself to a mold created by those who have come before.
 
#15
#15
I wonder about Neal being "lightning out of the backfield" in comparison to Young. DY's speed might be getting shorted a bit when you consider that this last track season only Jamol James topped Young's best 60m. The list of people with slower times includes R Neal.

At worst I'd have to venture that Young's speed is very comparable to Neal's.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 people
#16
#16
I wonder about Neal being "lightning out of the backfield" in comparison to Young. DY's speed might be getting shorted a bit when you consider that this last track season only Jamol James topped Young's best 60m. The list of people with slower times includes R Neal.

At worst I'd have to venture that Young's speed is very comparable to Neal's.

I am just not sure how many carries from rb DY would get anyways. Seems like a good wildcat option. That frame is too small for more than 3-5 carries a game when you add in the special teams blows he is going to take.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
#17
#17
I am just not sure how many carries from rb DY would get anyways. Seems like a good wildcat option. That frame is too small for more than 3-5 carries a game when you add in the special teams blows he is going to take.

Valid concerns. I'm curious to see what a full year of college offseason (plus just another year of maturity) has done for DY physically.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
#18
#18
UTGhostHunter, another nice write up. I disagree about Neal not having wiggle or elusiveness. He does and demonstrated it in the first game (Tenn. martin?) two years ago and i think with the Miss. game later on. His real problem is ball security. I do think with Lane and Devron breathing down his neck we will see a different Raijon this season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
#19
#19
UTGhostHunter, another nice write up. I disagree about Neal not having wiggle or elusiveness. He does and demonstrated it in the first game (Tenn. martin?) two years ago and i think with the Miss. game later on. His real problem is ball security. I do think with Lane and Devron breathing down his neck we will see a different Raijon this season.


Oh well then, he did it vs TN Martin 2 years ago. Whew, I feel so much better now.
 
#20
#20
What about Jaron Toney? He impressed me the most (effort wise) of the backs I saw last season, as surprised as I am to say that.
 
#22
#22
We will have a mediocre backfield with a below average offensive line again. We return the same crew this year on the OL and, based on their performance last year, they give me no reason to believe they will be that much better. The worst thing about this, however, is that we will have a hard time running out the clock against opponents. It's readily apparent that Chaney's plan is to run a pass first offense, intermingling the passing game with quick hitters by "scat backs" like Young and Lane. Unless we have an awesome defense, this won't work in the SEC.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
#25
#25
Alden Hill will be in the mix. He's the bowling ball, downhill, run up the middle weapon we seek. Opponents will be getting a regular dose of him by mid season.
 
Advertisement



Back
Top