BJ Coleman (Merged)

[kptvol]

lol at you comparing Casey Dick to Witten.

I'd say the difference between Witten's junior season and Finlayson's 98 year is about the same as Mitch's 8 games then benched performance versus what Dick did last year.

 

[kptvol]

lol at you comparing Casey Dick to Witten.

Aggrandizing the accomplishments of a guy that handed off to two first round draft picks is much better. The talent difference between 2006 Arkansas and 2008 Arkansas is greater than the difference between those two TEs.

 

[dickens821]

Aggrandizing the accomplishments of a guy that handed off to two first round draft picks is much better. The talent difference between 2006 Arkansas and 2008 Arkansas is greater than the difference between those two TEs.

Mustain would have started at Arkansas had he been there last year. It's really that simple.

 

[kptvol]

Mustain would have started at Arkansas had he been there last year. It's really that simple.

And he'd be benched this upcoming season in favor of Ryan Mallett.

I specifically said last season was better than anything Mustain would ever do, not anything Mustain might possibly do in a different dimension where he didn't make several idiotic decisions.

 

[dickens821]

I specifically said last season was better than anything Mustain would ever do, not anything Mustain might possibly do in a different dimension where he didn't make several idiotic decisions.

Last season Dick directed an offense that led Arkansas to an amazing 3-9 record, even with one of the best backs in the SEC to hand off to. Mustain 8-0. I'm still confused on how 3 > 8

 

[kptvol]

Last season Dick directed an offense that led Arkansas to an amazing 3-9 record, even with one of the best backs in the SEC to hand off to. Mustain 8-0. I'm still confused on how 3 > 8

I didn't realize Mustain and Dick took the field by themselves. Now, tell me how Peyton Manning is a choke artist and Tee Martin's jersey should be retired.

 

[KingNick865]

I didn't realize Mustain and Dick took the field by themselves. Now, tell me how Peyton Manning is a choke artist and Tee Martin's jersey should be retired.

You called?

 

[dickens821]

I didn't realize Mustain and Dick took the field by themselves. Now, tell me how Peyton Manning is a choke artist and Tee Martin's jersey should be retired.

8>3. Simple. Mustain has accomplished more in his limited career than Dick did last year. How you are debating this I don't know.

 

[kptvol]

8>3. Simple. Mustain has accomplished more in his limited career than Dick did last year. How you are debating this I don't know.

2500 yards > 800 yards. 47 TDs > 12 TDs.

Mustain rode the coattails of an extremely talented team. He did nothing.

And I didn't realize Michael Smith was the equivalent of Felix Jones and Darren McFadden.

 

[dickens821]

2500 yards > 800 yards. 47 TDs > 12 TDs.

Mustain rode the coattails of an extremely talented team. He did nothing.

And I didn't realize Michael Smith was the equivalent of Felix Jones and Darren McFadden.

8>3

 

[kptvol]

8>3

160 > 61

 

[dickens821]

8 continues to be more than 3.

 

[kptvol]

8 continues to be more than 3.

Now that I think about it, Mustain is at a 100% success rate. He must be the greatest QB that ever lived.

 

[LawVol13]

2500 yards > 800 yards. 47 TDs > 12 TDs.

Mustain rode the coattails of an extremely talented team. He did nothing.

And I didn't realize Michael Smith was the equivalent of Felix Jones and Darren McFadden.

I agree. Casey Dick was much more responsible for actually running the offense where Mitch Mustain had two beasts in the backfield. Obviously Arky won more with Mustain at quarterback, but it was certainly not because of him. I don't think Mustain would be playing if he was still at Arky.

 

[jjay2518]

Now that I think about it, Mustain is at a 100% success rate. He must be the greatest QB that ever lived.

You keep waffling between which one is better and which one accomplished more. You may think Dick is better, but Mustain has obviously accomplished more. Completion yards aren't accomplishments. Wins are.

 

[kptvol]

I agree. Casey Dick was much more responsible for actually running the offense where Mitch Mustain had two beasts in the backfield. Obviously Arky won more with Mustain at quarterback, but it was certainly not because of him. I don't think Mustain would be playing if he was still at Arky.

He might be playing if he were still there. As it stands, he'll spend the rest of his career on a bench.

 

[dickens821]

I agree. Casey Dick was much more responsible for actually running the offense where Mitch Mustain had two beasts in the backfield. Obviously Arky won more with Mustain at quarterback, but it was certainly not because of him. I don't think Mustain would be playing if he was still at Arky.

I guarantee he would have started this past year.

 

[kptvol]

You keep waffling between which one is better and which one accomplished more. You may think Dick is better, but Mustain has obviously accomplished more. Completion yards aren't accomplishments. Wins are.

Then I suppose John Brantley has accomplished more than either of them. I never said Dick was better.

 

[ballou1024]

May the name B.J. Coleman be stricken from all TN football records!

 

[Sudeepvol]

I guess Tee Martin was a better QB than Peyton Manning because he won a title.

 

[Sudeepvol]

You shouldn't base a QB's talent strictly on how many games his team won.

 

[KingNick865]

I guess Tee Martin was a better QB than Peyton Manning because he won a title.

vs.

With a National Title on the line, I'll take Tee Martin.

 

[dickens821]

I guess Tee Martin was a better QB than Peyton Manning because he won a title.

No one was arguing that. But thanks for the input.


Tee did accomplish more than Peyton though.

 

[utvolpj]

With a National Title on the line, I'll take Tee Martin.

a smarter person would take the 98 defense before either

 

[kptvol]

No one was arguing that. But thanks for the input.


Tee did accomplish more than Peyton though.

Tee Martin was not a liability around which the offense had to be reorganized in order to mask.