Yup. Some have suggested it's time to stop calling Kim "inexperienced," and after this year, I agree. But before this? Not so much. Pretty inexperienced. Consider her background:
* Played at Glenville State, including two years playing "the system" under Bunky Harkleroad. Hated it. Wanted to go home. then felt team drawing closer, saw it start to work.
* 3 years as an assistant under Harkleroad at Sacramento State.
* Hired as head coach back at Glenville State in2016, age 26. Brought her dad (her high school coach in for maturity, and her mom was "Team Mom"). 7 years, 6 conference championships (all except Covid year, 2020-21, the same year her father died), NCAA D2 Champ in 6th, Final 4 again in 7th.
* Went to Marshall, where she installed her system and won the conferencce chanpionship, taking the Thundering Herd to the NCAA for the first time since 1997.
* Recruited to Tennessee -- first year was surprisingly good, and she had a baby. Then, this year was a disaster. Admits she lost both players and coaches -- something that had never happened in her career.
Now, despite the "takes a long time to learn this system" talk -- that seems to be more Kim's critical, analytical approach. Look at her records in November and December. Her teams were winning. And they did that from YEAR ONE AT GLENVILLE STATE. What I'm saying here is that, in some ways, though I expect she learned things, her 7 years at Glenville State could be seen as much the same year, over and over. She ran her system (and it is hers -- she modified it from what Harkleroad ran), won lots of games, usually by big margins, and was phenomenally successful. Then she got one year at a mid-major D1, and, boom! Tennessee.
And she knew, even when she interviewed, that she had lots to learn. And said so.
From the SI article about her from last fall:
And how did she recruit players? With that same honesty. From the same SI article:
I got to admit, I was a little surprise how much Kim stuck by Zee this year, but maybe that's a hint. Repaying loyalty with loyalty, even when Zee was having trouble living up to her end of the bargain. And, on senior night, Zee's mother told Kim, "She made it!" That says something to me.
But today's a different day. Kim's got experience with a larger staff, and may have learned some very hard lessons. The overall format of a tough, demanding head coach and softer, more supportive assistant coaches generally works. It worked for Pat, and when Holly tried to take the "player-friend" role to the head coach position, not so much. Despite her comments early on about the possibility she would recruit players who might not be highly rated but would fit her system, it sure looks like she let herself deviate from that path. She mentioned how she'd never coached such tall, athletic players -- and that was with the 24-25 team. It sure looks like she may have fallen into recruiting highly-ranked players rather than the ones she needed. Lesson learned.
So, no longer inexperienced.
How's she going to go forward? I suspect she'll go back to basics. She's already said that about "the system." And the players she's going after in the portal so far seem to suggest that. Given what we know of her, I can't imagine that she's going to go away from the brutal honesty approach when she talks with players. In fact, she can now say, "You want to know what happens when everybody on the team doesn't commit to playing together and playing hard? It looks like last year. If you want to play the way my teams have played and earn what they earned, be ready to pay the price. You're going to run. You'll get less minutes, but plenty of possessions. And if you're subbed out after a couple of minutes and you're not tired, you should be asking yourself why, because you can sure I will be. I can tolerate mistakes. I can't and won't tolerate lack of effort."
I know this doesn't answer all the criticisms of "the system." Not trying to. I don't have that kind of expertise and don't know if they even have answers. Though the SI article does say she describes her offensive system as one "that actually ha
much of the pace and spacing of any savvy, modern team." What I am saying is that it seems a sure bet Kim Caldwell learned a lot about what she has to do to coach at Tennessee this year, maybe more than in the rest of her career combined. Sometimes, we learn more from failure than success.