Of course they have similar results, the "recruiting services" are cheating of the coaches' test. I don't think you understand how this works. The recruiting ranking is based on who is recruiting a player. So the recruiting services are just picking the same players as the coaches. These "services" are not out scouting players or watching film. If a player is recruited by top schools he's a four star, if he is recruited by all the top teams he's a 5 star. Purely a marketing and media construct and useless as teats on a boar hog. Forget the stars, cut out the middleman and just look at who is recruiting a player.