The grade is not the point, and I hope GMAC is wildly successful.
We’re all obviously on the outside looking in, but sitting here with 2 guys in the entire QB room with 9 college passes between them sure seems risky to me.
I didn’t even need Leavitt or Ty Simpson to make me feel better about the situation. Why not bring in a really productive senior FCS or D2 guy like Alonza Barnett, Amari Odom, or the Old Dominion QB to compete with GMAC and Faizon?
It's not ideal, no...of course, experience is great and something everyone would love to have, especially at QB. We took our swings at the "superstars" in the portal, and it didnt work out. However, countless times throughout the years, for countless schools, it hasn't played out perfectly, and true/redshirt freshmen have had to step up...and, many have been successful over many years.
Julian Sayin had thrown only 12 passes before this year; stepped in and completed 77% of his throws for over 3600 yards and 32 TDs.
In his 3 seasons prior, Ty Simpson had only thrown around 40/50 passes combined, before breaking out this year. Yes, he had seen much more action than George in those 3 years; but, he had not looked very good with those chances.
CJ Carr had never thrown the first pass in college, before completing 67% of his throws this year, for over 2700 yards and 27 total TDs.
CJ Stroud did not attempt a pass his freshman season, only seeing action in 2 games. His RFreshman season, he threw for over 4400 yards and 44 TDs, with only 6 picks, on 72% passing.
True Freshmen seasons...
Trevor Lawrence: 65% for 3300 yards and 30 TDs and only 4 INTs.
Sam Howell: 62% for over 3600 yards and 38 TDs and 7 INTs.
Jalen Hurts: 63% for 2800 yards and 23 TDs, and added 954 yards rushing with another 13 TDs. Almost 4000 total yards and 36 TDs.
I am not worried at all about George being the guy, and this is coming from a guy who was not impressed with him after watching his first game of his Sr season. Kept watching, and got impressed. Also, word coming out of last fall camp was he looked better than anyone, including Joey...just was too skinny; and, the reports continue to be nothing but positive about him...just has to put on weight. Word is, he can make any throw on the field, and his wheels are more than capable.
Now, we just need to go get some experience behind him and FB, just in case something does happen.