I would assess it this way. 21 contributers, 5 reaches that didn't pan out, and 4 academic casualties (which we should rarely ever see in the future under CDD).
Major Contributors (14)
QB - Simms (Started 7-8 games and very nearly beat LSU, to me thats a major contribution whether he was good or not)
QB - Bray
RB - Neal
WR - Rogers
WR - Hunter
TE - Rivera (JUCO)
OL - James
OL - Stone
OL - Fulton
DT - Jackson (transferred from USC - drafted)
DE - Smith
DE - Miller
S - Brewer (joined team from professional baseball)
K - Palardy (Hasn't lived up to hype but he's contributed for sure - still has time)
Minor Contributors (7
OL - Pair (really too early to tell because he redshirted but he's in the 2-deep)
DT - Clark
LB - Propst
LB - Fugate
LB - Sapp
LB - Crump
P - Darr (Has played but has a ways to go)
Reaches (5)
QB - Nance (We got what we needed here)
WR - Milton (transferred) (Poor evaluation from Kiffin and CDD had to roll with it given the circumstances)
DB - Meline (Not sure what Kiffin saw but he was never going to play here - left after position change)
DE - Jackson (transferred)(CDD took a chance to fill out the roster- same could be said of Clark, Probst, Sapp and Crump but they've contributed at varying levels)
Academic Casualties (4)
Probably none of these would have been takes had CDD had time to evaluate properly
DB - Clark (JUCO)
DT - Brown (JUCO)
DB - Loften
DB - Dixon[/QUOTE]