Call me crazy, but I'd offer the MVP of our Summer camp.
Think of the reaction Dooley would get if this guy is a beast in 3 years, and we didn't offer after he performed right under our coach's nose.
For every 1 "diamond in the rough" 2* recruit, there are about 50+ successful 4* recruits. I'd take my chances trying to get one of those 4*'s, statistically speaking.