Who did Urban Meyer beat at Utah (Pittsburgh in the Fiesta Bowl). This guy is the next up and coming guy, would be a great hire, and his style would really help recruiting.
let's just be real clear here, to underachieve is to not make it, and being called up to the majors in 2 years is far from underachieving. Some of the greats struggle early, let's see where he is in 2 more years then we can actually make an assesment on whether he is underachieving or not.