'14 TN WR Josh Malone (UT commit 12/4/13)

Status
Not open for further replies.
#5,381
#5,381
Mike Ferrell tweeted that there will be 6 new 5 stars added to the 2014 class after the next update. Could Malone be one of them?
 
#5,382
#5,382
secking said:
Yes he is. Beat Doofus all 3 years plus Butch this year. '10, 11, 12, 13. The worthless snake in the grass was 09.
Click to expand...

He was coaching the year Kiffins team beat the crap out of them.... no matter what you do you can't erase that loss. SMH
 
#5,389
#5,389
VonVol said:
Is there any chance they are going to drop Hurd from a 5 because of the injury? It seems as if they didn't want to give him that fifth star to begin with.
Click to expand...

Highly unlikely he drops. I do think Malone gets a 5th star. Garrett may as well. I still think Gaulden is the current commit who could/should make a huge jump.
 
#5,392
#5,392
Montrell Hardy said:
Highly unlikely he drops. I do think Malone gets a 5th star. Garrett may as well. I still think Gaulden is the current commit who could/should make a huge jump.
Click to expand...

The stars are supposed to represent the talent and potential of a player. Hurd's injury, at least IMO, does not reflect a drop in his talent or potential. If they drop him it will be a crock. Malone, Gaulden, and Garrett are also all beasts that should be talked about for a 5th star or at least be in the top 50 players in the nation.
 
#5,393
#5,393
glichtenwalter said:
The stars are supposed to represent the talent and potential of a player. Hurd's injury, at least IMO, does not reflect a drop in his talent or potential. If they drop him it will be a crock. Malone, Gaulden, and Garrett are also all beasts that should be talked about for a 5th star or at least be in the top 50 players in the nation.
Click to expand...

That is why I dont see him dropping. A shoulder injury doesn't affect your level of God Given talent. Either you are an elite talent or you aren't and Hurd is clearly one. And I agree on the other three. It will be interesting to see if they do anything with Gaulden. He has to be one of the 2-3 most underated prospects in this entire class.
 
#5,394
#5,394
Montrell Hardy said:
That is why I dont see him dropping. A shoulder injury doesn't affect your level of God Given talent. Either you are an elite talent or you aren't and Hurd is clearly one. And I agree on the other three. It will be interesting to see if they do anything with Gaulden. He has to be one of the 2-3 most underated prospects in this entire class.
Click to expand...

True, but kids get dinged in the rankings for poor grades all the time, and that has no bearing on their natural talent either. If they ding a kid for poor grades and how it could affect his ability to get/stay eligible, I wouldn't be surprised to see them ding a kid for an injury if they feel he is prone to injuries (which would justifiably affect his ability to stay on the field).

I'm not saying either case is right either. IMO, the rankings should reflect talent, and talent alone.
 
#5,395
#5,395
glichtenwalter said:
The stars are supposed to represent the talent and potential of a player. Hurd's injury, at least IMO, does not reflect a drop in his talent or potential. If they drop him it will be a crock. Malone, Gaulden, and Garrett are also all beasts that should be talked about for a 5th star or at least be in the top 50 players in the nation.
Click to expand...

You forgot Wharton I think he's highly underated too. Should be a high 4 star IMO. At the very least.
 
New posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
Advertisement





Back
Top