To quote Keith Jackson, "Whoa, Nellie!" You are badly distorting Dickey's record. First of all, he was 3-2-1 in head-to-head competiton wih Bear Bryant, winning the last three games of his tenure against Alabama. How many coaches can make that claim? As for bowl games, few coaches have consistently mastered the art of bowl preparation year in and year out. Even Neyland didn't have a stellar bowl record, going 2-5 in that category, with wins over Oklahoma (17-0) in the 1939 Orange Bowl and Texas (20-14) in the '51 Cotton Bowl. Do you want to challenge the venerable Neyland's coaching acumen as well?
Dickey beat Tulsa 27-6 in the '65 Bluebonnet Bowl and Syracuse 18-12 in the '66 Gator Bowl before losing to Oklahoma (26-24) on a 43-yd. field goal attempt by Karl Kremser that was wide right by about two feet. Flowers later said of the 36-13 loss to Texas that, "If we had played them ten times, Texas would have won all ten. They were that good." We were also facing the newly installed wishbone offense, which Darrell Royal debuted that season. As for the '69 Gator Bowl, news had already leaked that Dickey was going back to Florida and we simply did not play inspired football. Personally, I believe that, if he had not made the mistake of his life by going back home to his alma mater, Dickey could have retired from Tennessee with 200 victories or so, and 4-6 SEC titles. Bear Bryant's reign of terror over the SEC in the 1970s certainly would not have been as severe.