OK, so who is your list of best recruiters? I know after this season it is hard not to want the best on-the-field coaching, but truly recruiting does come first.
If we are talking about coaches that have been mentioned as possible candidates.
Gruden. (#1 choice for hire) I'll give you the fact he hasn't had to recruit at the college level, but name recognition alone has players lining up at the door. Coaching was successful at the pro level, unknown if it would translate in college.
Strong. But that doesn't mean I want him coaching here. I'm not 100% on his coaching yet. The two bad losses to end the year put a bad taste in my mouth. Love his Def mindset though.
Stoops. And coaches well. My #2 pick for the hire. Probably won't happen though.
Butch Davis. But does he do it ethically and within compliance?
Franklin. He's just a damn good recruiter. Not sure I like his coaching style though for the UofT.
Tressel. Not gonna happen, too much NCAA baggage.
Golden. I feel he is a better on-the-field coach than recruiter. He did ok at Temple, Miami he was hampered due to the NCAA probs.
I'm not saying Golden would be bad in the long or mid-term and not 100% against his hire, but a boom hire is needed. He's just not a boom and would be a settle hire IMO.
Patterson is my #3 choice by the way, he has to recruit Texas and gets alot of the cast offs from Texas, A&M, Oklahoma, etc. But he coaches them up extremely well, much like Golden.