Who is the better Manning?

[TrueOrange]

No wait, I mean Cooper


Cooper definitely is

 

[GetEmVols]

I would have used Barry Sanders in my argument, but I get what you are saying.

Lol thinking recent

 

[JonWard]

All-time? Hard to say.

LOL, not even close.

 

[005]

Peyton



Teams win championships

I wonder when the majority of earth will realize this.

 

[rickyyrs]

I wanted to get everyone's thoughts

When you go to the NFL your main goal is to win the Super Bowl. Eli 2 Super Bowls Peyton 1 Super Bowl :hi:

 

[Volsbackto1998]

I knew someone would start this again.

Peyton because he's a Volunteer

 

[GetEmVols]

I wonder when the majority of earth will realize this.

Even the media are morons about this simple concept.

 

[UrbanCryer]

hate to say but eli is $$ when the chips are down. ive seen peyton lose some big games. like 3 or 4 ints in the afc championship game to the pats. go ahead and flame me. i love peyton but eli is better. sorry

 

[MSCE09]

Peyton 9-10 in playoffs
Eli 8-3 in playoffs

 

[Vols4us]

Peyton. Eli has the benefit of a real defense that keeps the game close.

 

[volfan0320]

Peyton, but eli is a great qb also. So glad brady didn't get another ring. I'm sick of the greatest of all time crap

 

[UrbanCryer]

true with the defense comments. maybe peyton will go to the niners.

back to back to back

 

[GetEmVols]

Peyton 9-10 in playoffs
Eli 8-3 in playoffs

So you're saying Peyton makes the playoffs much more than Eli?

 

[Reformed Reader]

Cooper said he didn't see why winning Super Bowls was so difficult. Cooper said if he was playing he would have 5 by now. Archie said Peyton and Eli have better arms but Cooper only knows winning.

 

[LittleCat]

LOL, not even close.

Yes it is.

 

[badkarma]

He's going to Disney World

 

[bleedorange1983]

Eli is definitely more clutch, but Peyton is a MUCH better QB. Eli can't completely carry his team like Peyton can.

 

[UrbanCryer]

Cooper said he didn't see why winning Super Bowls was so difficult. Cooper said if he was playing he would have 5 by now. Archie said Peyton and Eli have better arms but Cooper only knows winning.

i lol'd

 

[005]

So you're saying Peyton makes the playoffs much more than Eli?

Peyton has had a longer career.. so.. Uh..

But, again. Peyton. Fact.

 

[UrbanCryer]

Eli is definitely more clutch, but Peyton is a MUCH better QB. Eli can't completely carry his team like Peyton can.

very true

 

[GetEmVols]

Eli had to score 21 to win the game today. Peyton would have had to score 35

 

[badkarma]

Peyton, but eli is a great qb also. So glad brady didn't get another ring. I'm sick of the greatest of all time crap

Couldn't agree more

 

[altidore17]

Take away Peyton from the Colts who went to the playoffs and they go 2-14.

/thread

BPC you are insane go back to your double wide.

 

[MSCE09]

So you're saying Peyton makes the playoffs much more than Eli?

Peyton had a head start and plays in one of the weakest divisions in the NFL. Eli plays in one of the two toughest divisions.

 

[LittleCat]

Take away Peyton from the Colts who went to the playoffs and they go 2-14.

/thread

BPC you are insane go back to your double wide.

You're not so good at using the ignore button are you?