Alabama or OSU in the BCSCG?

[govols120]

Every1 can argue up and down about this, but if we lost to a 6-6 Vandy team this yr, we would be out of the NC game picture

You know, I'm having a hard time disagreeing with this. (via Alabama's tight end Brad Smelley.)

 

[Ulysees E. McGill]

I don't give a damn how good Alabama is. They didn't win their division, let alone their conference. Send OSU.

OSU lost to Iowa freakin st. That all that needs to be said.

 

[Ulysees E. McGill]

I think Bama will go, but I'm hoping for OSU. LSU and Bama are the best two teams in the country but OSU may have a better resume than Bama.

How in the hell do you think OSU has the better resume?

 

[UTRavens]

The "two best teams" argument is a load of crap. If Iowa State missed a random field goal in regulation Oklahoma State would be undefeated, but that wouldn't make them better than they currently are. Bama would still be the "better team," so in that instance would they still have deserved to go?

I care about results, not hypotheticals. If that still makes Bama more favorable then okay, but the resumes should be the only thing that matter, not perception.

 

[DarthVisor]

OSU lost to Iowa freakin st. That all that needs to be said.

Who cares? Alabama had their chance, and they blew it. It's OSU's turn.

 

[Kvol87]

How in the hell do you think OSU has the better resume?

If you look at wins over ranked teams (and highest ranked teams) some one could make that argument. OSU would get that nod.

Plus the conference champ could help bolster the resume idea i guess.

Wouldn't you think?

 

[DarthVisor]

Interesting.

Oklahoma State has defeated seven teams with winning records. Alabama has defeated three.

Oklahoma State has defeated five BCS Top 25 teams. Alabama has defeated two.

 

[SamRebel35]

How in the hell do you think OSU has the better resume?

They've beaten more ranked teams than Alabama.

 

[Ulysees E. McGill]

Who cares? Alabama had their chance, and they blew it. It's OSU's turn.

Osu had a easier chance and blew it....Iowa st? Are you freakin kidding me?

 

[DEFENDTHISHOUSE]

Interesting.

Oklahoma State has defeated seven teams with winning records. Alabama has defeated three.

Oklahoma State has defeated five BCS Top 25 teams. Alabama has defeated two.

And there we have it sports fans.

 

[DarthVisor]

Osu had a easier chance and blew it....Iowa st? Are you freakin kidding me?

Alabama had a shot at LSU AT HOME and couldn't get the job done. They don't deserve another shot.

 

[govols120]

This guy is projecting OSU to finish second. We'll just have to wait and see...

https://twitter.com/#!/BCSGuru

 

[Ulysees E. McGill]

Winner of that crap conference is a joke. How many ranked teams outside of their inflated rankings conference did they beat? Stinking Texas was still in the top 25 before today with 4 losses. Big12 or whatever they are now is a joke.

 

[Kvol87]

Osu had a easier chance and blew it....Iowa st? Are you freakin kidding me?

Conference loss in which they went on to win though.

 

[SamRebel35]

And there we have it sports fans.

It won't matter in the end. Alabama has been talked up by the media outlets so much this year that the perception about them is that they are the only solution for the number 2 spot.

 

[Ulysees E. McGill]

Alabama had a shot at LSU AT HOME and couldn't get the job done. They don't deserve another shot.

Did Green Bay deserve to be the super bowl champions last year? This why there should be a freakin 4 team playoff at least. At the end when it matters.

 

[vols-1]

Does anyone outside the SEC even have an argument? they turned down a playoff already.

"In 2008, commissioner Mike Slive pitched a so-called “plus-one” plan that essentially was a four-team playoff using existing bowl games. Other than the ACC, the other conferences not only summarily rejected the plan, they refused to even discuss its details."

SEC reaps reward of rejected playoff plan - College Football - Rivals.com

 

[SamRebel35]

Winner of that crap conference is a joke. How many ranked teams outside of their inflated rankings conference did they beat? Stinking Texas was still in the top 25 before today with 4 losses. Big12 or whatever they are now is a joke.

Oh, so ranked teams only count when they are SEC ranked teams. Got ya.

 

[DarthVisor]

Winner of that crap conference is a joke. How many ranked teams outside of their inflated rankings conference did they beat? Stinking Texas was still in the top 25 before today with 4 losses. Big12 or whatever they are now is a joke.

Who did Alabama beat from outside of the conference that is worth a damn? Before you answer, please remember that Penn State is not worth a damn.

 

[DarthVisor]

Did Green Bay deserve to be the super bowl champions last year? This why there should be a freakin 4 team playoff at least. At the end when it matters.

I agree about the playoff.

 

[Ulysees E. McGill]

Oh, so ranked teams only count when they are SEC ranked teams. Got ya.

What do you think? If you think osu is better than Bama, say so.

 

[SamRebel35]

What do you think? If you think osu is better than Bama, say so.

We can't know the answer to that. The only thing to look at is their resumes.

 

[Ulysees E. McGill]

Nobody should be allowed to play for the NC that loses to their respective conferences version of vanderbilt.

 

[DarthVisor]

Nobody should be allowed to play for the NC that loses to their respective conferences version of vanderbilt.

Why not?

 

[Ulysees E. McGill]

We can't know the answer to that. The only thing to look at is their resumes.

Alabama would chew anybody else in the nation up and spit them out, and you know it. They are the only team that has a legitimate shot at beating LSU.