Gerrymandering in Virginia

Absolutely, as individuals they were all flawed, but the collective really did something beautiful. A lesson we should take to heart right about now.

The variety of ideas and perspectives, along with spirited, sincere, thoughtful debate gave birth to one of the best governmental systems in history.

I ponder, with the benefit of hindsight, what would Jefferson, Hamilton, Adams, etc do differently from the beginnning, if anything. Also, what adjustments would they make now?

What would they say about citizens united? What would they say about all of the amendments enacted? What would they say about the two party system as it currently stands? All of it (too much to mention). I ponder this often. I do the same with Teddy Roosevelt (I’m admittedly a fanboy).
George Washington spoke out against political parties. Warned how they would divide the nation. Read his Farewell Address. GW was a freakin' psychic.
 
Thomas Jefferson would not have been amused by Lincoln’s antics. Hamilton likely would have been a huge fanboy.

Did you watch the HBO series John Adams? It was excellent imo, and explored the complex relationship between Adams and Jefferson.
I like to think GW would kick ol' Abe's ass.
 
Thomas Jefferson would not have been amused by Lincoln’s antics. Hamilton likely would have been a huge fanboy.

Did you watch the HBO series John Adams? It was excellent imo, and explored the complex relationship between Adams and Jefferson.
Yep, I own the box set. Probably watched it 4 or 5 times over the years. Paul Giamatti, Laura Linney, David Morse… all fantastic work.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 85SugarVol
I don’t necessarily disagree with you, but this is an idea floated to improve the representation citizens get in Washington.
Curb the salaries, force everyday travel like citizens. It would force them to be among and work for us. It's not a bad idea at all. Their positions weren't intended to be professions, it was a civic duty. We've created a political class that we pay to abuse and take advantage of us.
 
Curb the salaries, force everyday travel like citizens. It would force them to be among and work for us. It's not a bad idea at all. Their positions weren't intended to be professions, it was a civic duty. We've created a political class that we pay to abuse and take advantage of us.
Yep
 
Senate doesn’t represent the citizenry. That is the role of the House, and why California has more Representatives than the states mentioned combined.

Senate represents the States. They are all equal, irrespective of population. Which is what the founders wanted.
States are full of people. States have no voice,its citizens do. States don't elect senators, it's citizens do that. Might as well have a blind draw.
 
Curb the salaries, force everyday travel like citizens. It would force them to be among and work for us. It's not a bad idea at all. Their positions weren't intended to be professions, it was a civic duty. We've created a political class that we pay to abuse and take advantage of us.

Limit congress to 90 days in session per year, reduce pay accordingly.
No pension, no health care.
Build a dormitory with cafeteria for them to stay in while in session, no perdiem.
As you said, it was never meant to be a career.
 
States are full of people. States have no voice,its citizens do. States don't elect senators, its citizens do that. Might as well have a blind draw.
Are those citizens in the WHOLE state not using their voice when they elect their Senators. What if you are an Independent and you vote for a Democrat Congressman and a Conservative Senator or the other way around.
 
Limit congress to 90 days in session per year, reduce pay accordingly.
No pension, no health care.
Build a dormitory with cafeteria for them to stay in while in session, no perdiem.
As you said, it was never meant to be a career.
any interest in continuing the convo about expanding the number of congressional reps?
 
I’m open to being convinced it’s not an idiotic galacticly stupid idea.
This is where we left off.

Understood. I cannot guarantee your views would be better represented either.

But if you had increased likelihood to have a face to face convo and dialogue about your views and why you held them would your chances of being accurately represented increase or decrease?

any feedback?
 

Advertisement



Back
Top