Recruiting Forum Football Talk IX

Bama had what was considered the best win by winning in Athens. They also had what was considered the worst loss to FSU. When they got blown out in the SEC CG, they should have lost their spot in the CFP. This whole "de-incentivize" CGs grab is BS. Everyone still wants to win their conference. If the games are going to matter, they should matter both ways. If the game had been close, I would agree with the argument of Bama inclusion. It wasn't. They should be out. But because they are Bama, they get more preferential treatment than any other program.

If you punish CG losers, you’re incentivizing teams to not want to play in their CG.

And ND shouldn’t be allowed in the CFP until they join a conference. And if they are not in a conference, no team ahead of them the week before the final rankings that loses their CG should drop below them.

They have to figure out that out and fix it.
 
Last edited:
Didn't help that a young and immature Vols team was sitting at 8-3 with nothing to play for, but completely agree. I really hate that so many of our own posters think the name of the team dictates the outcome.

That Vandy team has as much of a case for being in the CFP as Bama, OU, Miami, and even Notre Dame...but of course no one is talking about that because they're Vandy.
The frustrating part is that we lost to every good team on our schedule and struggled against a few others. But yes, losing to Vandy is not embarassing. Tough team. Now, let's get some strong talent in the portal and actually beat some good teams next year. Schedule is only getting harder.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MoCo_Vol
The simple truth is that in year 5, given the steady improvement in talent, there is no justification for being nearly last in the conference. I assure you that UGA or Bama wouldn't accept it. Why are we? Everyone deals with injuries. Why do ours make being the worst acceptable?
Well it would be refreshing to hear someone on the fire Banks train give some specific football reasons for why Banks is so terrible and should be fired. All they spout is stats and rankings. Googling stats and rankings is all non-ball knowers do.
 
Well it would be refreshing to hear someone on the fire Banks train give some specific football reasons for why Banks is so terrible and should be fired. All they spout is stats and rankings. Googling stats and rankings is all non-ball knowers do.
Well that's what 95% of posters on this message boards does... So your theory is only 5% of the people on here knows "ball", interesting..



The stat Nerds are gathering their information as I type...
 
Last edited:
Well it would be refreshing to hear someone on the fire Banks train give some specific football reasons for why Banks is so terrible and should be fired. All they spout is stats and rankings. Googling stats and rankings is all non-ball knowers do.
I know exactly nothing about football schematics. Other than, relying on what I see others talk about.

I just know we are slow on D, and cant stop the run. Also, we take bad angles, and play OOP, as well dont get to QB when we blitz.

Ive said, its a Jimmy's and Joe's thing. Banks didnt forget how to call plays overnight.
 
If you punish CG losers, you’re incentivizing teams to not want to play in their CG.

And ND shouldn’t be allowed in the CFP until they join a conference. And if they are not in a conference, no team ahead of them the week before the final rankings that loses their CG should drop below them.

They have to figure out that out and fix it.

Virginia was punished, North Texas was punished, BYU was punished....the only CG loser that wasn't punished was Bama.

Ohio State went from 1st to 2nd
BYU from 11th to 12th

But what basically happened was Miami moved up 2 spots and Bama didn't move at all...seems the committee was just looking at the name of these teams and not resumes.
 
Well it would be refreshing to hear someone on the fire Banks train give some specific football reasons for why Banks is so terrible and should be fired. All they spout is stats and rankings. Googling stats and rankings is all non-ball knowers do.
He is paid to field a successful defense. Those stats and rankings are the evidence that he did not do that. We got whipped by Vandy. At home. Does that make it easier to understand?
 
Virginia was punished, North Texas was punished, BYU was punished....the only CG loser that wasn't punished was Bama.

Ohio State went from 1st to 2nd
BYU from 11th to 12th

But what basically happened was Miami moved up 2 spots and Bama didn't move at all...seems the committee was just looking at the name of these teams and not resumes.

All of those teams were already out of the playoff before the CG sans BYU (or were they out also despite being #11?) who was 1 spot behind ND and stayed 1 spot behind ND.

OSU dropped 1 spot bc of h2h.
 
Virginia was punished, North Texas was punished, BYU was punished....the only CG loser that wasn't punished was Bama.

Ohio State went from 1st to 2nd
BYU from 11th to 12th

But what basically happened was Miami moved up 2 spots and Bama didn't move at all...seems the committee was just looking at the name of these teams and not resumes.
Alabama should be playing at Texas A&M not Oklahoma...
 
All of those teams were already out of the playoff before the CG sans BYU (or were they out also despite being #11?) who was 1 spot behind ND and stayed 1 spot behind ND.

OSU dropped 1 spot bc of h2h.

Miami was too, before Duke beat Virginia...they jumped ND who also didn't play.

That's what is frustrating if neither team played then why did their ranking change?

1765209720332.png1765209739955.png
 
Doesn't really matter what we the fans think. Matters what DW, and Donde, and Randy think. We'll see how it plays out but I truly believe he's safe until after the '27 season because sanctions will end before the '28 season.
Don't get me wrong, I want Coach here and succeeding. And you're right about who will make the decision. I was speculating on butts-in-seats based on fan's patience levels.
 
Miami was too, before Duke beat Virginia...they jumped ND who also didn't play.

That's what is frustrating if neither team played then why did their ranking change?

View attachment 796790View attachment 796791

Yea the committee sucks. Miami should’ve been ahead of ND already due to h2h.

This is why they should do away with weekly rankings and just drop the final rankings on everyone’s head.
 
"Well first of all I'd like to say what a tremendous honor it is to play in the Xbox Bowl. I took a poll the other day and 37% of our team grew up with PlayStations instead of Xboxes so this is going to be a tremendous challenge for us."
"You think about the XBox, and overcoming adversity. They had the red ring of death. At Arkansas State we have the red ring of trust."
 
Request for prayers. As some know, I took a life-changing job in DC that started in September. In October we had our second child. I haven't had any time off and we knew it would be a challenge, but we didn't factor in how difficult this would all be for our oldest daughter (3.5yo).

We knew there would be an adjustment, but she's very obviously dealing with anxiety and probably depression. Multiple times a day she cries because she misses her friends from her old preschool. Multiple times a day she asks to call or facetime her grandparents, aunts, and cousins, something she never asked to do before we moved. While out she will go from being happy and in the moment to panicking and asking for her blanket or to be held.

We know part of that is being a 3yr old learning how to regulate emotions. And her imagination is definitely coming in full swing now. It's just been hard for us to watch and manage especially.

We are trying our best. We call family daily, we do fun things on weekends as often as possible, we are trying to make this Christmas a magical one, she's at a new school now slowly making new friends. Also hoping to start going to church where she's in school to create more of a connection for her and us. We also talked last night and plan to sit down with her and create a very structured schedule to alleviate some of her anxiety and help her and us manage each day. We just need some encouragement, prayers, and support.

And we need the Vols to play a bowl game so she can run around screaming "Woo!" As I sing Rocky Top and celebrate touchdowns.

Thanks y'all.
Definitely, Soil. Just keep the faith. Things will work out.

I remember that my daughter went through some stuff about that age. Similar to you, we had our second child about the same age. The dynamics changed, obviously. She had to adjust to being the sole attention of mommy and daddy to splitting time with baby brother. It didn't take long for her to adjust. The good thing (for me 😅) is she was forced to spend more time with me.
 
We shouldn’t need first round talent and many draft picks to field a top 30 defense. That’s just excuses. I think it’s more clear that Pearce and other draft/nfl players masked what banks is. And why would it matter who the fans want? That’s on Josh and Danny to figure out. The fact is Banks is not good and is going to get Josh in some hot water if he retains him.

I would go get a young innovative up and coming DC and let them run. Plenty of names coming up.
I’m good with getting young innovative DC. Banks has had a top 30 defense in 3 of his 5 seasons. I don’t think you definitely need NFL players but you need solid veteran players. We can fix that issue with transfers. We have missed on too many High School kids.
 

Advertisement



Back
Top